Cover of The Butt Plug Predicament

The Butt Plug Predicament

Read the story

4 chapters · 9985 words · Read 1 times

Ryan is a college junior with long brown hair, a beard, and tattoos. Channah is a senior with red hair with bangs, porcelain skin, huge breats, and great curves. Ryan sits behind her in their psychology lecture class. One day, he notices her skirt in an awkward position that reveals that she’s wearing a butt plug.

Chapter 1: The Revelation in Row Five

The fluorescent lights hummed overhead, casting a sterile, unforgiving glow over the rows of scarred wooden desks. Chalk dust hung in the air, a fine, bitter powder Ryan could almost taste on his tongue. Professor Davies’ voice, usually a compelling baritone that dissected Freudian slips and Skinner boxes with equal relish, droned into a meaningless static buzz. Ryan’s pen hovered above his notebook, the cheap blue ink leaking a tiny blot onto the page. He’d been sketching the intricate patterns of the radiator cover near the window, a nervous habit.

His gaze drifted, restless. It landed, as it often did during these Tuesday/Thursday lectures, three rows ahead and to the right. Channah.

Her vibrant red hair was a shock against the drab institutional beige of the lecture hall walls, cut sharply with thick, straight bangs that framed her face. Her posture was perfect, spine straight, head tilted attentively towards the front. A black turtleneck sweater hugged her curves, disappearing into the high waist of a dark green, knee-length skirt. She looked effortlessly put together, untouchable. Ryan knew her name only from roll call. Channah. The quiet redhead who always sat alone, radiating a self-contained confidence that both intrigued and intimidated him. Her flawless porcelain skin seemed to glow faintly under the harsh lights.

Professor Davies was pacing now, gesturing emphatically. "...and so, the perceived boundary between conscious control and unconscious impulse is far more porous than we readily admit! We curate our external presentations meticulously, yet beneath the surface..." He paused, tapping the lectern. "...beneath the surface, primal drives, hidden desires, they simmer. They inform our choices in ways we rarely acknowledge. Who here feels truly, entirely known?"

A nervous titter rippled through the room. Ryan found himself staring at the smooth curve of Channah’s neck where it met the black wool of her sweater. His own arms, sleeveless beneath a worn flannel shirt, felt suddenly exposed, the intricate lines of his ink – a coiled serpent, geometric patterns, lines of poetry – stark against his skin. His rebellion felt juvenile compared to her quiet composure.

Then she shifted.

It wasn't a big movement. Just a slight adjustment in her seat, crossing one leg over the other, perhaps trying to get more comfortable on the unforgiving wood. The hem of her green skirt rode up, just a fraction, revealing the backs of her thighs above her knee-high socks.

And there it was.

Caught in the relentless glare of the overhead fluorescents, nestled snugly against the delicate lace edge of her black underwear, was an unmistakable glint.

A small, jeweled stone. Deep blue, maybe sapphire. Set in what could only be the base of a plug.

Ryan’s breath hitched, loud in his own ears. The static in his head roared, drowning out Davies completely. His pen slipped from numb fingers, clattering onto the desk. The radiator sketch blurred. His pulse hammered against his ribs, a frantic drum solo against the sudden silence in his skull.

That… that can’t be…

His eyes snapped back to her face, half-expecting her to be looking at him, horrified. But Channah was still facing forward, her expression unchanged. Serene. Attentive. As if she hadn’t just detonated Ryan’s entire perception of her, of the room, of reality itself. The quiet redhead wasn’t just hiding her thoughts. She was hiding this. Something profoundly intimate, defiantly carnal, right here in the sterile, chalk-dusted air of Psych 301.

Heat flooded Ryan’s face, a prickling wave that swept down his neck. He felt dizzy. The image was seared onto his retinas: the porcelain skin, the curve of her thigh, the startling, illicit sparkle against black lace. Primal drives. Hidden desires. Davies’ words echoed grotesquely. Ryan’s mouth went dry. He desperately tried to look away, to focus on his fallen pen, on the radiator, on anything else. But his gaze kept snapping back, magnetized to that tiny, impossible sparkle. Was it real? Had he imagined it? He hadn’t. The cold fluorescence left no room for doubt.

Another small shift. Her skirt settled back down, covering the revelation as casually as smoothing a wrinkle. The glimpse lasted less than three seconds. But Ryan felt fundamentally altered. The quiet redhead was a labyrinth. A secret wrapped in porcelain skin and red hair. And he’d just stumbled through a hidden door he couldn’t unsee.

He became hyper-aware of everything. The scrape of a chair. A cough. The frantic scribbling of the girl next to him. The scent of chalk felt suddenly cloying, thick. He forced his hand to retrieve the pen, his fingers clumsy and cold. He stared at the ink blot on his page. It looked like a dark, shapeless stain. Appropriate.

The remaining twenty minutes of the lecture were an agonizing blur. Davies’ voice washed over him, meaningless syllables. He kept his eyes rigidly fixed on his notebook, sketching jagged, meaningless lines. He didn’t dare look up again. The weight of the secret pressed down on him, heavy and electrifying. His mind raced, fragmented thoughts colliding. Why? How? Who is she? The image replayed relentlessly – the smooth skin, the lace, the cold, hard sparkle of the jewel. It felt surreal. Obscene. Fascinating.

When the harsh bell finally shattered the tense quiet, jolting Ryan like an electric shock, the scrape of dozens of chairs was deafening. Students surged towards the exits, a wave of chatter and rustling backpacks. Ryan stayed frozen for a moment, gathering his scattered books with trembling hands, deliberately slow. He needed space. Air.

He risked a glance. Channah was already standing, adjusting the strap of her leather messenger bag. She moved with the same effortless grace, completely unruffled. Was she aware? Had she felt his stare boring into her back? His heart hammered again.

He shuffled into the aisle, keeping his head down, trying to blend into the stream of bodies flowing towards the double doors. He felt exposed, raw. As he neared the exit, a familiar flash of red caught his peripheral vision. She was right beside him, merging with the crowd near the doorway. Too close. The scent of her perfume – something warm and subtly spicy, like amber and vanilla – cut through the chalk dust. It was unexpectedly comforting, yet intensified his disorientation.

He couldn’t help it. His eyes flickered sideways, scanning her profile. Her expression was neutral, focused on navigating the crowd. Then, as if sensing his gaze, she turned her head. Her eyes – a startling shade of green, like moss on wet stone – locked directly onto his.

No embarrassment. No anger. Just a cool, appraising look. Direct. Unflinching.

Ryan felt his cheeks burn anew. He looked away instantly, staring at the scuffed linoleum floor, his throat tight. He braced for… what? Accusation? Disdain?

Instead, her voice cut through the hallway noise, low and clear, devoid of any discernible emotion. It landed right beside his ear.

"See something you like, tattoo guy?"

The casualness of it, the utter lack of shame or even surprise, was more shocking than the glimpse itself. His head snapped up. She wasn't smiling, wasn't smirking. Her gaze was steady, challenging almost, but also… curious? He opened his mouth, but his tongue felt thick, useless. All that came out was a strangled, unintelligible noise. "I… uh…"

She held his gaze for a beat longer, those green eyes seeming to see right through his flannel, his ink, his stunned silence. Then, without another word, she smoothly turned and walked away, her red hair swinging, melting into the throng of students heading towards the quad.

Ryan stood rooted to the spot just outside the lecture hall doors, the current of students parting around him like water around a stone. The bright sunlight streaming through the high windows felt jarringly harsh after the fluorescent cave. Her words echoed. "See something you like, tattoo guy?" Casual. Dismissive. Utterly destabilizing. He felt simultaneously seen and obliterated.

The warm vanilla-amber scent of her perfume lingered, a ghostly taunt. He stared after the vanished spot of red, his mind churning. The jeweled glint, the impossible contrast between her serene composure and that hidden secret, the directness of her gaze… it wasn’t arousal he felt primarily, though that flickered uneasily beneath the surface. It was a profound sense of vertigo. The ground beneath his carefully constructed observations – the quiet redhead, the untouchable enigma – had cracked open, revealing something dark, complex, and dangerously magnetic.

"Ryan! Earth to Ryan!"

Cameron’s voice, loud and cheerful, broke through his daze. His friend sidled up, clapping him on the shoulder. Cameron had been sitting near the back, probably texting more than taking notes. "Dude, you look like you just saw a ghost. Davies fry your brain with the id-ego-superego stuff again?"

Ryan flinched at the contact. He forced himself to turn, trying to school his features into something resembling normalcy. "Nah. Just… zoning out." His voice sounded rough, unfamiliar. "Long lecture."

"Tell me about it," Cameron groaned, falling into step beside him as Ryan finally started moving, propelled more by Cameron’s momentum than his own will. "Seriously, though, you okay? You’re pale. Like, extra pale."

"Yeah, fine," Ryan muttered, shoving his hands deep into his pockets. The image flashed again – thigh, lace, sapphire sparkle. He felt nauseous. "Just need some air. Real air." The quad’s open space felt suffocating now.

Cameron shrugged, easily distracted. "Cool. Hey, you catch the game last night? Brutal loss." He launched into a play-by-play Ryan didn’t hear.

They pushed through the main doors into the crisp autumn afternoon. Students milled everywhere – laughing groups, solitary figures with headphones, couples holding hands. Normalcy. Ryan felt utterly detached from it. His eyes scanned the crowd, an involuntary reflex, searching for that shock of red hair. He didn’t see her. Relief warred with a strange disappointment.

He needed to process. Needed to be alone. Needed to… forget? Or understand?

"Cameron," he interrupted his friend’s monologue about a missed field goal. "Gonna bail. Head back to the dorm. Not feeling great." It wasn’t entirely a lie. His stomach churned uneasily.

Cameron stopped, concern briefly replacing his easygoing expression. "Whoa, seriously? You want me to walk with you? Grab some greasy fries? Cure-all."

"Nah, man. Thanks." Ryan managed a weak smile. "Just need to crash. See you later." He didn’t wait for a reply, turning sharply and heading down a less crowded path towards the older dorm buildings, away from the main flow.

He walked fast, shoulders hunched, the flannel shirt suddenly too warm despite the cool breeze. He veered off the path, ducking behind the massive, ivy-covered bulk of the library. Finding a shadowed alcove near a service entrance, hidden from view, he stopped. Leaning his forehead against the cool, rough brick, he squeezed his eyes shut.

But closing his eyes only made the image brighter in the darkness behind his lids. The jewel. The contrast of the hard stone against her soft skin. Her cool green stare. "See something you like?"

He retched. Nothing came up but bile, burning his throat. He spat onto the concrete, breathing hard. Shame washed over him – shame at his reaction, shame at his inability to stop looking, shame at being so completely seen and dismantled by her indifference.

He pushed off the wall, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand. His tattoos, symbols of his carefully cultivated detachment, felt like meaningless scratches. Professor Davies’ voice echoed again, haunting him: "Who here feels truly, entirely known?"

Channah wasn't known. She was a carefully constructed enigma with a hidden, glittering core. And Ryan, the quiet observer, the one who thought he saw the patterns, had been blindsided. He felt exposed. Vulnerable. Intruding on a secret he couldn't comprehend.

He looked out from the alcove, back towards the bustling quad. The world seemed suddenly sharper, more dangerous. He felt a confusing pull – a desperate desire to see her again, to understand the contradiction she embodied, warring with a primal urge to run far away from the unsettling disturbance she’d caused in his ordered world. She wasn't just a quiet redhead. She was a walking, talking exploration of boundaries Davies had only theorized about. The porcelain skin hid a fire he couldn't begin to understand, and he’d just gotten scorched by a stray spark.

He took a deep, shuddering breath. The taste of bile lingered. The only clear thought piercing the chaos was terrifyingly simple: he needed to see her again. Not because he wanted to. Because he had to. It wasn't desire; it was compulsion. The quiet redhead was the most dangerous thing on campus, and she was the only thing he wanted to see.

The next psychology lecture loomed like a verdict. Ryan spent the intervening days in a haze of fragmented thoughts and restless nights. The image of the sapphire plug against black lace, Channah’s cool green stare, the scent of amber and vanilla – they cycled through his mind on a relentless loop. He avoided Cameron’s easy chatter, skipped meals, and found himself sketching jagged, abstract shapes in his notebook that always morphed into unsettling curves and hard, glittering points. The library alcove became his refuge, the cool brick a grounding counterpoint to the heat simmering under his skin. Need warred with dread. He had to see her again, even if it burned him.

Tuesday arrived, grey and damp. Ryan entered the lecture hall twenty minutes early, a strategy born of desperation. He needed to be settled, braced, before she arrived. He chose a seat further back this time, diagonally behind her usual spot. Less obvious. Safer. Maybe. The fluorescent lights buzzed their familiar sterile song. Chalk dust tickled his nose. He gripped the edge of the worn wooden desk, knuckles white, his tattoos stark against the tension. Students trickled in, filling the space with low murmurs and the rustle of bags. His eyes scanned the doorway like a hunted animal.

She arrived just as Professor Davies began shuffling notes at the lectern. Not late, but commanding attention nonetheless. A ripple seemed to pass through the air near the door as she walked in. Today, her fiery hair was pulled back in a severe, high ponytail that accentuated the sharp angles of her face. She wore a deep burgundy sweater dress, soft-looking wool that clung to her curves, ending mid-thigh. Black sheer tights. Knee-high black leather boots with a modest heel. Effortless. Untouchable. Again.

Ryan’s breath hitched. She slid into her seat three rows down and slightly to his right, her movements fluid and economical. She arranged her bag, pulled out a notebook, and settled. Professor Davies launched into a discussion about cognitive dissonance, his voice a resonant background hum against the frantic thudding in Ryan’s chest.

He forced himself to look at his own blank page. Don’t look. Don’t fucking look. His pen trembled. Davies paced, gesturing towards the whiteboard. “...the discomfort of holding contradictory beliefs, the psychological imperative to resolve the tension...”

Ryan’s eyes betrayed him. They flickered sideways, drawn by an impossible gravity.

The burgundy dress had ridden up slightly as she sat, just enough. The sheer black tights offered little concealment. Nestled against the shadowed cleft of her ass, unmistakable under the harsh light, was a different sparkle. Not sapphire blue. This time, it was a deep, blood-red jewel. A ruby. Larger than the first. Set in a wider, more ornate silver base. It gleamed, wet-looking, nestled against the sheer fabric.

Fuck. Fuck. Fuck.

His pulse roared in his ears, drowning Davies completely. His cock stirred traitorously, a hard, insistent pressure against his jeans. Heat flooded his face, prickling down his neck. He felt dizzy, nauseous, furious at his own helpless reaction. He couldn’t tear his gaze away from that obscene, glittering intrusion. Primal drives. Hidden desires. Davies’ words from the previous lecture echoed, taunting him.

She shifted. Just a subtle adjustment, crossing her legs at the ankles this time. But it was enough. Her head turned, not fully, just a fraction. Her profile sharp against the beige wall. And her eyes – those cool, moss-green eyes – slid sideways. Not towards the front. Towards him.

Locked onto his.

No surprise. No challenge this time. Just… acknowledgment. A knowing, unsettling calm. She saw him staring. Saw the flush on his face, the dilation of his pupils, the rigid tension in his shoulders. She held his gaze for a long, excruciating second. Davies was drawing a diagram on the board, his back turned. The student beside Channah was diligently copying notes. The girl in front of Ryan was texting under her desk.

Only Ryan saw the slow, deliberate shift in her expression. A subtle arch of one dark eyebrow. A flicker of something dark and satisfied in the depths of her green eyes.

Then, with a grace that was almost casual, she moved. One hand slipped down, disappearing behind her back, hidden from the view of the students beside and in front of her by the angle of her body and the bulk of her bag resting against her chair leg. Ryan saw it all. Saw the flex of her forearm beneath the burgundy wool. Saw the subtle tensing of her shoulder.

He saw her fingers, pale against the dark fabric, reappear.

Clenched between her thumb and forefinger was the jeweled plug.

The ruby glistened, slick with a clear, viscous sheen. It caught the fluorescent light, throwing tiny crimson sparks onto the desk beside her notebook.

Ryan stopped breathing. The world narrowed to that glistening red stone and her hand. Davies’ voice was a distant murmur. The scrape of pens faded. He felt simultaneously frozen and vibrating with horrified, electric arousal.

Slowly, deliberately, Channah raised the plug towards her face. Her eyes never left Ryan’s.

Her tongue, pink and wet, snaked out. Not a quick flick. A long, deliberate lick. From the wide silver base, up the smooth curve of the tapered stem, swirling slowly around the ruby itself. Collecting the wetness. Her lips parted slightly. Ryan could almost hear the slick sound, his mind filling in the obscene detail.

She held his stare, a silent dare burning in her eyes. Then, her lips closed around the ruby.

She sucked.

Hard. Like it was a fucking lollipop. Her cheeks hollowed slightly. A slow, obscene pull. Her tongue working the stone inside her mouth. Her eyes, wide and unblinking, pinned Ryan to his seat. It was intimate. Violating. A performance staged solely for him in the middle of the crowded, oblivious lecture hall. Degrading. Hypnotic.

A low groan threatened to tear itself from Ryan’s throat. He choked it back, a strangled sound lost in the ambient noise. His cock was painfully hard, straining against his zipper. Sweat slicked his palms. His stomach churned violently. He wanted to vomit. He wanted to shove his hand down his pants. He wanted to run screaming from the room. He couldn’t move. Couldn’t look away. Trapped by her green gaze and the sight of her sucking on that slick, red jewel pulled from her own body.

After an eternity – three seconds? Ten? – her lips released the plug with a soft, wet pop that Ryan felt in his own balls. A thin strand of saliva stretched briefly between her lower lip and the glistening ruby before breaking. Her tongue flicked out once more, catching a stray droplet at the corner of her mouth.

Still holding his gaze, a ghost of a smirk playing on her lips now, she lowered her hand. It disappeared behind her again. Ryan saw the subtle shift in her posture, the minute tension as she guided the wet plug back into place. A faint shudder ran through her, barely perceptible. Then her hand reappeared, resting innocently on her notebook. She uncrossed and recrossed her ankles, smoothing the burgundy dress back down over her thighs.

The ruby sparkle vanished.

She turned her head fully back towards the front, picking up her pen as if nothing had happened. Davies was asking a question. A student near the front answered. The lecture hall hummed with normalcy.

Ryan sat rigid, drenched in cold sweat, his heart hammering against his ribs like a trapped bird. The taste of bile was back, acrid and sharp. The phantom scent of her – amber, vanilla, and something darker, muskier, intimately her – filled his nostrils. His mind reeled. What the fuck was this? Some kind of punishment? A game? A test?

The dismissal bell was a physical shock. Students erupted into motion, chairs scraping, voices rising. Channah stood smoothly, gathering her things with that same unsettling calm. She didn’t look back. She simply merged with the stream of students heading for the door, her burgundy form disappearing into the corridor.

Ryan remained seated long after the hall had emptied, staring at the spot where she’d been. The air still vibrated with the echo of her silent, devastating act. He felt flayed open. Utterly exposed. More lost than before. The quiet redhead wasn’t just dangerous. She was a force of nature, playing with him in ways he couldn’t comprehend. The boundaries Davies lectured about weren’t just porous; Channah had ripped them down and used the debris to build an altar to something Ryan was terrifyingly desperate to understand, even as it promised to destroy him. He had no choice but to follow the trail of glittering, wet jewels.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI