Cover of The Butt Plug Predicament

The Butt Plug Predicament

Read the story

4 chapters · 9985 words · Read 1 times

Ryan is a college junior with long brown hair, a beard, and tattoos. Channah is a senior with red hair with bangs, porcelain skin, huge breats, and great curves. Ryan sits behind her in their psychology lecture class. One day, he notices her skirt in an awkward position that reveals that she’s wearing a butt plug.

Chapter 3: Double the Pleasure

The air in the abandoned lecture hall hung thick and still, charged with the raw musk of sweat and sex. Dust motes drifted lazily in the jaundiced light of the single bulb, indifferent spectators to the scene below. Ryan’s thighs burned from the awkward squat, his face buried deep between Channah’s spread cheeks, his tongue working relentlessly in the tight, slick heat of her asshole. Her taste – musky, salty, deeply intimate – flooded his senses, drowning out everything but the pounding of his own blood and the wet sounds of his own mouth on her flesh. Her hand, slick with her own juices and his spit, pumped his cock with rough, demanding strokes.

He was lost. Completely consumed. The quiet observer who usually lived inside his skull had been obliterated, replaced by pure, desperate sensation. His world narrowed to the rhythmic clench of her ass around his tongue, the firm slide of her hand on his cock, the overwhelming scent of her arousal thick in the stale air. He groaned, the sound muffled against her skin, vibrating against her sensitive flesh.

Suddenly, Channah’s grip tightened painfully on his cock, halting his thrusting tongue. She pushed back hard against his face, grinding her ass against his mouth with a low growl. "Enough," she rasped, her voice raw. "Fucking enough."

Ryan pulled back, gasping for air, his lips and chin slick and shining. He looked up, bewildered, disoriented, his cock twitching painfully in her unyielding grip. His vision swam, the dusty room tilting slightly.

In one fluid, powerful motion, Channah spun around. Her burgundy sweater dress was still bunched around her waist, revealing the flushed, wet triangle of her pussy, glistening and swollen. Her green eyes blazed with feral intensity, locking onto his. Before he could react, she shoved him backwards. Hard. He stumbled, catching himself against the edge of the heavy wooden table.

"No more fucking teasing," she snarled, closing the distance between them in a heartbeat. Her hands were on his jeans again, yanking them and his boxers down past his hips in one brutal pull. His cock sprang free, thick and flushed, straining upwards. She didn't hesitate. She grabbed his shoulders, her fingers digging in. "Down," she commanded, shoving him forcefully backwards again.

Ryan’s ass hit the scarred surface of the table. The impact jolted through him. Before he could even register the sensation, Channah had hiked her dress higher, gripped his hips, and swung one leg over him, straddling his lap. Her weight settled onto him, warm and demanding. Her hand snaked between their bodies, fingers finding his cock, guiding it unerringly to her entrance. He could feel the incredible heat radiating from her core, the slick wetness coating his tip.

She didn't lower herself slowly. She didn't ask. With a sharp intake of breath, she slammed herself down onto him, impaling herself on his cock in one forceful, desperate plunge.

"FUCK!" Ryan choked out, his head snapping back, his fingers scrabbling for purchase on the smooth wood beneath him. The suddenness, the sheer tight, wet heat engulfing him, was almost blinding. She was incredibly tight, her inner walls clenching like a velvet fist around his cock, slick with her arousal. It was a different sensation entirely from her asshole – hotter, softer, yielding and demanding all at once. Deeper.

Channah didn't give him time to adjust. She let out a guttural moan that vibrated through his entire body, her head thrown back, exposing the pale column of her throat. Her eyes were squeezed shut, her brow furrowed in intense concentration, or perhaps relief. "Yes… oh god, fuck… finally," she gasped, her voice thick and ragged.

She started to move. Not gentle rolls of the hips, but sharp, demanding bounces. She rode him hard, driving herself down onto his cock with punishing force, using his lap for leverage. Her hands braced against his chest, fingers digging into the fabric of his t-shirt, likely leaving bruises beneath. Her breasts, constrained by the dress and her bra, heaved with each desperate thrust.

The table groaned in protest beneath them, shuddering with the force of her movements. The sound echoed in the dusty silence, mingling with the wet slap of skin on skin and their harsh, panting breaths. Ryan could only hold on, his hands instinctively gripping her hips, fingers sinking into the soft flesh above her ass. He tried to lift to meet her downward surges, but she controlled the rhythm completely, setting a brutal, demanding pace.

"God, you feel big," she moaned, her eyes fluttering open to meet his gaze. There was a raw hunger there, a fierce possessiveness. "Filling me up… stretching my fucking cunt…" Her words were filthy, explicit, designed to inflame. She ground down hard, circling her hips, making him feel every intimate contour. "Is this what you wanted, Ryan? Hmm? This tight little pussy wrapped around your cock?"

He couldn't speak. Could only groan, a low, animal sound torn from his chest. His hips jerked involuntarily, trying to thrust upwards, but she kept him pinned, controlling the depth, the angle. She leaned forward, her breasts pressing against his chest, her mouth hovering near his ear. Her breath was hot, ragged. "You liked licking my ass, didn't you? My dirty little secret hole?" She punctuated the question with a particularly hard downward slam that forced the air from his lungs. "Bet you want to fuck it next, huh? That filthy boy cock deep in my ass?"

The image, the raw vulgarity of her words coupled with the incredible sensation of her pussy gripping him, sent a jolt of white-hot lust straight to his core. He bucked beneath her, an uncontrolled spasm. "Channah… fuck…"

"Yes!" she hissed, sensing his unraveling control. She sat up straight again, riding him even harder, faster. Her movements became more erratic, less controlled, driven by a building urgency. Her hands flew to her breasts, roughly kneading them through the fabric of her dress, pinching her own nipples hard enough to make her gasp. "Don't stop… don't you fucking stop… make me cum! Fuck me harder!"

Ryan surrendered completely. The dam broke. He released his grip on her hips and thrust upwards with all his strength, meeting her downward lunges with powerful drives of his own. The table scraped loudly against the floor. The sound of their joining became obscenely loud – wet, rhythmic smacks echoing off the bare walls. He buried his face in the curve of her neck, inhaling the intoxicating mix of sweat, vanilla, and her unique, musky scent. He bit down gently on the delicate skin, not enough to break it, but enough to make her cry out.

"Yes! Bite me! Fucking own me!" she screamed, her body arching backwards. Her cunt clamped down on his cock with shocking, rhythmic intensity. Wave after wave of her orgasm gripped him, milking him relentlessly. Her inner muscles fluttered and pulsed, a silken vice around his shaft.

The sensation was too much. The visual of her lost to ecstasy, the overwhelming tightness, the sheer force of her release pulling him over the edge. With a ragged shout that tore from his throat, Ryan slammed up into her one final time, burying himself to the hilt. His body locked, rigid, as his own climax erupted, hot and searing. He pulsed inside her, spurt after spurt flooding her depths, a deep, guttural groan escaping him as his vision blurred at the edges.

He held her there, impaled, trembling as the last tremors of his release shuddered through him. Channah collapsed forwards against his chest, her body limp and trembling, her breath coming in ragged, wet gasps against his neck. Her sweat-slicked skin stuck to his. They were locked together, a sweaty, trembling tangle of limbs on the scarred wooden table, the only sound their harsh breathing and the frantic drumming of their hearts.

The silence of the room rushed back in, thick and heavy. The dust motes continued their slow dance in the weak light. The forgotten ruby plug lay gleaming dully on the dusty floorboards nearby. Ryan’s mind, slowly emerging from the drugged haze of pure sensation, registered the sticky wetness cooling between them, the ache in his muscles, the utter, devastating intimacy of their position. He was still buried inside her. Her weight was solid, real, anchoring him in the aftermath.

He lifted a trembling hand, unsure where to put it, finally letting it rest lightly on the damp fabric covering her back. She didn't move. Her breathing seemed to slow, becoming deeper, but she didn't lift her head. He felt her heart pounding against his chest, a frantic echo of his own slowing rhythm. The quiet observer stirred within him, taking stock: the smell of sex and dust, the chill of the room finally penetrating the heat of exertion, the impossible reality of Channah

Her weight pressed him deeper into the rough wood, the scent of sex and her skin thick in the stale air. The frantic drumming under his palm gradually eased, a counterpoint to the aftershocks still trembling through his own limbs. He felt impossibly full, impossibly connected, her slick heat still clamped around his softening cock, trapping him in the aftermath. Dust motes drifted, indifferent.

Channah stirred first. She pushed herself up off his chest, the movement causing a slick pull inside her that made Ryan gasp. Her green eyes, still dilated but regaining their sharp edge, scanned his face. Sweat plastered strands of fiery red hair to her temples. A faint, satisfied smirk touched her lips as she lifted herself off him completely, his cock slipping free with a wet sound that echoed loudly in the quiet.

"Up," she commanded, her voice raspy but regaining its iron tone. She slid off the table, her dress falling back to her knees, momentarily hiding the mess between her legs. She pointed to the dusty floor beside the table. "Lie down. Now."

Ryan obeyed, clumsy in his exhaustion, his jeans still tangled around his thighs. He lowered himself onto the cold, gritty floorboards, wincing as the rough wood scraped his back. His cock, still thick and semi-hard, glistened wetly in the weak light. He watched Channah, bewildered, as she kicked off her shoes with impatient flicks of her feet.

She didn't hesitate. Straddling his chest, she faced his feet, her knees bracketing his head. The burgundy wool of her dress was rucked up around her hips again as she lowered herself. Her ass hovered directly over his face, the glistening pink pucker he’d just been devouring inches from his mouth. Her wet cunt was a dark, swollen shadow just above. Simultaneously, she reached back and grasped his cock firmly, positioning it near her lips.

"Back to work, tattoo boy," she ordered, her voice muffled slightly as she leaned forward. "Lick. Everywhere. Make me fucking wet again." She then bent her head, her fiery red hair falling like a curtain, and took the head of his cock deep into her mouth without preamble.

The sensation was immediate and overwhelming. Her mouth was hot, wet suction, her tongue swirling expertly around his sensitive tip. He groaned, arching his back off the floor. The scent of her sex, her ass, flooded his nostrils again. He could see the ruby plug, forgotten nearby, glinting dully. He obeyed. He pressed his face upwards, his tongue finding her asshole first, lapping at the tight, salty ring still slick from his earlier ministrations. He traced upwards, lathing broad strokes over her perineum, feeling the coarse hair, then delving into the hot, swollen folds of her pussy, tasting her fresh arousal mixed with his own release.

Channah moaned around his cock, the vibration traveling straight to his groin. She sucked him harder, taking him deeper, her head bobbing with a hungry rhythm. Her free hand braced on his thigh, fingers digging in. His tongue worked furiously, circling her clit, plunging into her cunt, then returning to her asshole, driven by her muffled sounds of pleasure and the punishing suction on his cock. It was a filthy feedback loop: his tongue driving her wild, her mouth milking his rising arousal. Sweat beaded on his forehead, trapped under the furnace of her body. The taste of her, the intense sensation – it was consuming him again.

"Fuck yes, just like that," she gasped, pulling off his cock with a wet pop, a string of saliva connecting her lips to the glistening head. She gave his shaft two rough, quick strokes. "Keep licking that ass, you fucking deviant. Get it ready." She immediately plunged back down, taking him deep into her throat this time, making him cry out, his hips bucking involuntarily. Her ass ground down onto his mouth, demanding he push his tongue deeper inside her tight hole. He did, spearing into her, fucking her ass with his tongue while she deepthroated him with guttural urgency.

Just as the pressure in his balls began to build dangerously, she pulled off again, panting. She pushed herself upright, dismounting him in a swift motion. "Enough sucking." She spun around, presenting her back to him, and bent forward sharply at the waist, bracing her hands on the scarred table edge. Her ass thrust back, the glistening target presented once more. "Fuck my ass. Now. Use your goddamn cock."

Ryan scrambled to his knees, fumbling to push his jeans further down his legs. His cock throbbed, painfully hard again, slick with her spit. He shuffled forward on his knees, positioning himself behind her. The sight was obscene: her smooth cheeks spread, her asshole pink and glistening from his tongue, her pussy dripping wet below it. He gripped his cock, the head slick, and guided it towards the tight ring of muscle.

"Spit on it," Channah commanded, glancing back over her shoulder, her eyes blazing. "Make it slick. Then push in. Slowly. Feel me stretch."

Ryan spat thickly onto the head of his cock, rubbing it over himself. He pressed the blunt tip against her asshole. There was resistance, a tight clenching. He pushed, steady pressure, feeling the incredible, impossible tightness yield fraction by fraction. "Fuuuck," he hissed through gritted teeth as the head finally popped past the ring, engulfed in searing, clenching heat.

"Yesss," Channah groaned, pushing back against him. "More. Give me more, Ryan. Fuck it into me." He pushed forward, inch by agonizing inch, feeling her asshole stretch to accommodate his girth, the friction intense, almost painful, but incredibly stimulating. She was incredibly tight, hotter than her pussy, gripping him like a fist. He bottomed out, his balls pressed against her slick folds. They both gasped.

He paused, buried to the hilt, overwhelmed. She was trembling. "Move," she demanded, her voice strained. "Fuck me. Hard."

He pulled back slowly, feeling every ridge, every clench, then thrust forward again. A groan tore from both of them. He set a rhythm, slow at first, deep thrusts, savoring the unbelievable tightness, the way her muscles gripped and massaged his cock. The sound was obscene: wet, slapping flesh, their ragged breaths, the scrape of his knees on the dusty floor.

Suddenly, Channah reached back with one hand, groping blindly until she found his hip. "Stop." Her voice was tight. "Pull out. Slowly."

Confused but compliant, Ryan eased his cock out of her ass, slick and shining. Before he could process, she twisted at the waist, dropped to her knees facing him, and lunged forward. Her mouth engulfed his cock again, sucking fiercely, her tongue swirling over the swollen head, tasting her own ass on him. "Mmm, fuck," she moaned around him, sucking hard, taking him deep, her hand working the base. She pulled off, spit shining on her lips. "Tastes so fucking dirty. Perfect." She sucked him again, deep and wet, for a few more desperate seconds before pulling off with another sharp pop.

"Back in," she commanded, spinning back around and bending over the table again, presenting herself. "Harder this time. Fuck my ass like you mean it."

Ryan didn't hesitate. He grabbed her hips hard, lined himself up, and slammed back into her tight hole in one forceful thrust. She cried out, a sound of pure, sharp pleasure-pain. He started fucking her in earnest now, hard, deep strokes, pulling almost all the way out before plunging back in, the force of his thrusts rocking her body against the table. Her ass rippled with each impact. He felt her muscles clamp down rhythmically, milking him.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI