Chapter 2: The Tree Farm
On Friday I took my fiancé shopping at the Second Chances thrift store on Route 9, and he rejected four sport coats in a row for reasons I did not understand.
"The shoulders are wrong," he said of the first one.
"They're shoulders. They're where shoulders go."
"They're built for a man who slouches." "The second one's fused, not canvassed. The third one is polyester pretending to be wool, which I find personally offensive. And the fourth one has a stain shaped like Ohio."
"Who taught you about canvassing?"
He gave me a look. Condition one: no questions about the past.
"Fine," I said. "Keep your tailoring secrets. But you need something for the tree farm that isn't that coat, because my mother can spot a cuff fray from across a parking lot."
We settled on a red-and-black buffalo plaid jacket, a pair of work boots only half a size too big, and a gray knit hat that he put on in the mirror and then stood very still, looking at himself like a man meeting a cousin he'd heard bad things about.
"You look like you sell artisanal maple syrup," I said.
"Is that good?"
"In Bellmont? That's practically royalty."
We built his past over pancakes at the Starlite Diner, on the back of my legal pad.
Name: Nick Holloway. I picked Holloway because it sounded like a man who owned a canoe. Job: marine engineer, which explained the hands and the dishwasher and gave us an excuse to send him to Alaska in January. How we met: the Hartwell wedding in October, where he'd been a guest on the groom's side and had fixed the chocolate fountain when it started spraying the bridesmaids.
"In our version you're very good with your hands and you asked me to dance, and I said no because I was working, and you waited until the last song and asked again."
He was quiet, cutting his pancake into exact squares. "What was the last song?"
"I don't know. Something slow." I tapped my pen on the pad. "Does it matter?"
"Your sister's going to ask."
"Bea is going to ask," I agreed, and wrote down "At Last," because it seemed right and because I didn't want to look at him while I did it.
Then he reached into the pocket of the plaid jacket and set a small, worn velvet box on the table between the syrup and the ketchup.
I stared at it. "What is that?"
"You can't be engaged without a ring. Your mother would notice."
I opened it. Inside, on faded blue satin, sat a slim gold band with a single small sapphire, the old-fashioned kind, set low and square, the gold worn soft at the back from someone else's years of wearing it.
"Nick." I didn't touch it. "Where did you get this?"
"Pawnshop," he said, to his pancakes.
It wasn't from a pawnshop. I've planned forty-one weddings. I know what a pawnshop ring looks like, and I know what a ring looks like when somebody has kept it in a drawer for a long time because they couldn't bear to sell it. I opened my mouth. He looked up, and the gray eyes said: condition one.
I put the ring on. It fit like it had been waiting.
"Thank you," I said. "I'll give it back. After."
"I know you will," he said, and signaled for more coffee.
Hollis Tree Farm sits on a hill outside town, and on the Saturday before Christmas it looks like somebody shook a snow globe and set it down very gently. The snow had come overnight, just like he'd said. Four inches, soft as flour, on every branch of every Fraser fir in forty rows.
The Carvers arrived the way we always arrive, which is in three vehicles, all at once, with the horns going.
"There she is!" My father was out of his truck before it had fully stopped. Ray Carver carried mail in Bellmont for thirty-four years and still walks like the whole town is on his route. "There's my girl! And there's..." He stopped two feet from Nick and looked up. And up. "Well. They grow them big in the marine engineering business."
"Mr. Carver." Nick held out his hand. "Nick Holloway. Thank you for having me."
My father shook it, then didn't let go, then pulled him into a hug that lifted Nick's heels a quarter inch off the snow. Over my father's shoulder, Nick's eyes found mine, wide and alarmed, like a cat being picked up by a stranger at a party.
"He hugs," I mouthed.
"I see that," he mouthed back.
Then my mother, Patti, in her good white parka, who looked at the ring before she looked at his face and then held my hand up to the light like she was checking a twenty. Then Bea and her wife Tamsin, Bea already narrowing her eyes. Then Uncle Sal, holding a thermos that was definitely not coffee. Then a scrum of cousins, and finally my grandmother Lou, levered out of the back seat of Bea's car in a cardigan covered in knitted reindeer.
She walked straight up to Nick, all four feet nine of her, and peered at him through her enormous glasses.
"Bend down," she said.
He bent. She took his chin in her mittened hand and turned his face left, then right, the way she checked cantaloupes at the grocery store.
"Huh," she said. "You'll do." And she let go and marched off toward the cocoa stand.
"What was that?" Nick murmured.
"That was a pass," I said. "She made Colin take off his sunglasses and then told him he had shifty ears."
The Carver tree tradition is simple. My father picks the tallest tree on the farm. My mother says no. They argue for forty minutes. We buy the tree my grandmother points at in the first five.
This year, my father had a new angle.
"You're a big fella," he said, handing Nick the bow saw with the air of a man passing the Olympic torch. "Let's see what marine engineering does with a nine-foot Fraser."
"Dad," I said.
"It's fine," said Nick.
"Dad, he doesn't have to..."
"June." Nick shrugged out of the plaid jacket and handed it to me. Under it he was wearing the gray thermal from the shelter, the sleeves pushed up. "It's fine."
He knelt in the snow at the base of the tree, studied the trunk for a second, cleared the low branches with one sweep of his forearm, and set the saw. Then he cut. Long, even strokes, no wasted motion, his breath going up in white clouds. Twenty seconds. Thirty. The tree shivered, leaned, and came down exactly where he'd meant it to, onto a clean patch of snow, without a single branch snapping.
There was a beat of silence on the hill.
"Well," said Uncle Sal, and passed him the thermos.
My father looked at the tree, then at Nick, then at me, and his eyes went shiny in a way I hadn't seen since my sister's wedding. "Marine engineering," he said thickly. "Who knew."
Nick stood up, brushing snow off his knees. He caught me looking and raised one eyebrow, a tiny question: too much?
I shook my head. I was holding his jacket against my chest, and it smelled like cold air and cedar and the cheap shelter soap, and I'd been holding it too tight.
It was at the cocoa stand that Colin happened.
I should have known. The Hollis farm is the only real tree farm in twenty miles. Everybody goes. But I'd been so busy managing my fake fiancé that I'd forgotten to manage my real past, and there it was, in a quilted vest, holding hands with a blonde woman who was laughing at something he'd said, which meant she hadn't known him very long.
"Junie!" Colin said. He was the only person on earth who called me Junie, and I had asked him to stop on our second date. "Wow. Merry Christmas! This is Kristen."
"Hi," said Kristen, warmly. She seemed nice. That was the worst part.
"I heard you were..." Colin's eyes dropped to my hand. To the sapphire. They stayed there a second too long. "Oh. Wow. Congratulations."
"Thank you," I said, and my voice came out thin and high, like a balloon losing air.
And then a large warm hand settled at the small of my back, and Nick was beside me, a paper cup of cocoa in his other hand, which he offered to me as though we were the only two people at the stand.
"Marshmallows," he said. "You said you wanted the big ones."
I hadn't said that. I took the cup.
"Nick Holloway." He shook Colin's hand. Briefly. Correctly. The way you might shake hands with a man at a funeral whose name you'd been told and immediately forgotten. "You must be the one from last year."
Colin's smile went stiff. "I guess word gets around."
"It does." Nick's voice was perfectly pleasant. "June planned that party, didn't she? The whole thing. I heard it was beautiful." He paused. "You should have stayed for the cake. I hear she's very good."
Kristen's eyebrows went up. Colin opened his mouth, shut it, and found something urgent to look at on the far side of the parking lot.
"Merry Christmas," said Nick, and steered me away with that hand on my back, unhurried, toward the trees.
I didn't say anything until we were three rows deep in the firs, out of sight of everyone, snow squeaking under our boots. Then I stopped.
"You didn't have to do that."
"I know." He looked down at me. "Did you want me not to?"
I thought about it honestly. About a year of being the poor thing. About my mother's voice on the phone, careful, like I might break. About standing in that coat closet last Christmas Eve while Colin explained, very reasonably, that he'd realized he wanted someone more spontaneous.
"No," I said. "I wanted you to do exactly that. I wanted someone to do exactly that for a whole year."
"Then you're welcome." He frowned at my hands, wrapped around the cocoa cup. "Where are your gloves?"
"In my car. I forgot. I always forget. I remember everyone else's gloves..."
He took the cup, set it on a fence post, and took both my hands in his. Then, without a word, he tucked them into the deep front pockets of the plaid jacket, which he was wearing again, and held them there, his own hands closed over mine through the flannel.
It was warm in there. Ridiculously warm. I stood with my hands in his pockets and my forehead about three inches from his collarbone, and I couldn't think of a single thing to say, which had never happened to me in thirty-one years.
"You plan everybody's Christmas," he said quietly, over my head. "Who plans yours?"
"Nobody," I said into his jacket. "That's not how it works."
"Hm," he said. It sounded like a man taking a note.
On Sunday night he stayed for dinner at my apartment, because my mother had sent us home with a lasagna the size of a suitcase, and because by then it felt strange to drop him off at St. Brigid's and drive away.
I was clearing plates when my laptop chimed on the counter. Work email. My biggest client of the year: a corporate holiday gala on the twenty-second at the Ellery Hotel in Philadelphia, three hundred guests, a string quartet, an ice sculpture of a cargo ship that I'd personally had to argue down from a forty-foot ship to an eight-foot one.
"Oh no," I said, reading. "Oh, no, no, no. My assistant quit. She's moving to Phoenix with a man she met on a cruise. Three days before the biggest event of my career."
Nick looked up from where he was drying my one good pot, a dish towel over his shoulder exactly like Dolores. "Can I help?"
"Can you wear a tux, carry a clipboard and keep three hundred drunk executives away from an ice ship?"
"I've done worse."
"I'm serious. I'll pay you for that too. Separately. It's a real job." I turned the laptop toward him. "The new CEO wants everything gold. Gold napkins. Gold chargers. He asked if we could do gold-leaf on the shrimp."
Nick leaned over my shoulder to look. I felt him go still. Not a flinch. Something quieter than that, like the room had lost a degree of heat all at once.
The email was signed: Graham Pierce, Interim Chief Executive Officer, Northgate Freight.
"Northgate," I said. "Did you know there was a big shake-up there? Something on the news. The old CEO just disappeared, apparently..."
And I stopped.
Because I was suddenly thinking about the old television in the corner of the dining hall. About a glass tower in the snow. About a hand reaching up to change the channel without looking. About a photograph on the screen for half a second: a clean-shaven man in a navy suit, unsmiling, with eyes the color of a February sky.
I turned around slowly in my chair.
Nick was folding the dish towel into a precise square, corner to corner, the way he'd folded that napkin for Mr. Abernathy. He didn't look at me.
"I'll do it," he said. "The gala. I'll be there."