Chapter 3: Christmas Eve on Larkin Street
I didn't ask him that night. I want that on the record.
I sat in my kitchen with a lasagna pan soaking in the sink and a man I'd known for five days folding my dish towel into smaller and smaller squares, and I said, "Condition one," out loud, mostly to myself. He looked at me then, finally, and the relief on his face was so naked that I had to turn back to my laptop and pretend to read about gold-leaf shrimp.
I'm a planner. I know what happens when you open a door before you're ready for what's behind it.
So instead, on Monday, I took him to cookie day.
Cookie day is held in my grandmother's kitchen, which is the size of a phone booth, and involves nine kinds of cookie and no recipes, because Lou keeps them all in her head and believes writing them down is how the government gets them. Nick was assigned to the pizzelle iron. He was very bad at it. He burned the first six, and my grandmother made him eat every one.
I was in the hallway hunting for more parchment when I heard her say, low, "I read the paper, young man. The real one. With ink."
Silence from the kitchen. The pizzelle iron hissed.
"I haven't told her," Lou went on. "I'm eighty-eight. I've learned when to keep my mouth shut, and it's almost never, but this is one of those times." A pause. "Whatever you're running from, you ran into us. That's not nothing. Don't you dare make her sorry."
"No, ma'am," Nick said. His voice was rough. "I won't."
I went back into the kitchen with the parchment and pretended I'd heard nothing, which was easy, because Lou immediately accused me of over-rolling the snowballs.
Then I counted the tins. Nine. There had been one more when Colin was around. She'd quietly retired his favorite, and she'd never said a word.
The Ellery Hotel ballroom on the night of the twenty-second looked exactly like money had been poured over it and left to set. Gold napkins. Gold chargers. Gold garland on every chandelier. The eight-foot ice cargo ship gleamed by the bar like a very cold, very expensive argument I'd won.
Nick wore a rented tux and carried my clipboard and was, for three hours, the best assistant I've ever had. He knew which executives to seat away from the bar. He knew how to talk the quartet's cellist down from a panic attack. He moved through three hundred people in his beard and his borrowed bow tie, and not one of them looked twice at him, because nobody looks at the help. I'd always known that. I'd never watched someone use it.
At nine-thirty, Graham Pierce got up to give his toast, all teeth and tan and camel cashmere, and Nick disappeared.
I found him in the service corridor behind the kitchen, between a rack of dirty glassware and the walk-in cooler. Graham had found him first.
"Nicholas," Graham was saying. He'd left his own toast to follow, which told me everything about how scared he was. "My God. You look like a lumberjack's disappointing son."
"Graham." Nick's voice was one I'd never heard before. Every syllable cut and squared. "You gave the board a fake audit. You told them I'd buried the safety reports on the Camden terminal. You signed my name to them yourself."
"That's a big accusation for a man who's been sleeping in a church basement."
"Elaine kept copies. Of everything. She always does." Nick held up his phone. "The board has them as of this afternoon. I thought you should hear it from me. We were friends for a long time."
Graham's face went through several weather systems. Then his eyes slid past Nick and found me, standing at the end of the corridor with my clipboard pressed to my chest.
"Oh, that's good," he said slowly. "That's very good. Is that the planner? You got yourself hired onto my event staff to get in the door?" He laughed. "I always said you were the smartest man in the building."
Nick turned. Saw me. And I watched him understand what I'd just heard and what it sounded like, and I watched him not say anything fast enough.
"Was it the job?" I said. My voice didn't shake. I was proud of that later. "Was that why you said yes? Was I just a way in?"
"June..."
"Because I can work with that. I'm a professional. I'd just like to know which event I'm actually running."
Two security guards came around the corner, the hotel's and someone else's, and Graham started talking very loudly about trespassing, and a woman in a gray suit I didn't know appeared behind them saying "Mr. Wilde" in a voice that meant business. In the noise, I walked back out to the ballroom, because there were three hundred people and an ice ship and a dessert service in half an hour, and nobody plans those but me.
When I looked for him at midnight, he was gone.
On the twenty-third, the story was on every channel. The Northgate board had reinstated its chief executive. Its interim chief executive was "on leave pending review." There was a new photograph: Nicholas Wilde on the steps of the glass tower, clean-shaven, in a navy suit, unsmiling.
Dolores called me at seven a.m.
"He came by last night," she said. "Two in the morning. Cleared out bunk nine. Fixed the side door so it locks. Left something for you."
It was an envelope. Inside was the check I'd written him for the deposit, uncashed, and a single sheet torn off a legal pad, folded into a precise square.
It said: I said yes because of Graham. I said yes again every day after that because of you. I don't know how to prove that, so I'm not going to try tonight. Go caroling. Your father will be heartbroken if you miss the high note.
I went caroling. I missed the high note. My father was heartbroken. Everyone asked where Nick was and I said, "Work thing," which was technically the truest thing I'd said all week.
Christmas Eve on Larkin Street starts at five. By four-forty, I was sitting in my car at the curb with the engine running and a plan.
The plan was simple. I'd go in. I'd wait until everyone had a drink. I'd stand up before the toast, the way Colin had stood up in that coat closet, and I'd tell them the truth: there was no fiancé. There was a man I'd hired, and then liked, and then more than liked, and he had a whole other life an hour away in a glass tower, and the ring was going back in its box. They would be kind about it. That was the part I couldn't stand. They'd be so kind.
I twisted the sapphire off my finger, put it in my coat pocket, and got out of the car.
He was sitting on my parents' front steps.
He'd shaved. That was the first thing. Without the beard, his face was all angles, younger and more tired at once, a man I'd seen on a television screen and never met. He was wearing the charcoal coat, but someone had fixed the cuffs, and on his lap was a pie box from the Starlite.
He stood up when he saw me. Snow had collected on his shoulders. He'd been there a while.
"Your grandmother," he said, "called me at noon and said that if I wasn't here by five with a coconut cream pie, she'd come to Philadelphia herself."
"Lou has your number?"
"Lou has everyone's number. I'm fairly sure she has the governor's." He held out the box like a peace offering. "The diner was out of coconut cream. I bribed the cook."
I didn't take it. I stood at the bottom of the steps with my hands in my pockets, one of them closed around the ring. "You didn't cash the check."
"I didn't need it. I never did." He came down one step. "I needed a reason to be somewhere for a week that wasn't hiding. You gave me five. A tree farm. A cookie day. Your father's terrible tenor. You." Another step. "I'd been in that shelter for three weeks planning how to get my company back. Then a woman with a legal pad asked me to pretend I loved her, and I spent eight days trying to remember how pretending was supposed to go."
My throat had gone tight. "Graham said..."
"Graham was half right. I did take the gala job for him. For about four minutes." He was on the bottom step now, just above me, so for once we were eye to eye. "Then you showed me the email and I sat at your kitchen counter thinking: if I tell her, she'll think I used her. If I don't, I'm using her. I was a coward. I picked the one that let me stay for dinner."
The front window was bright behind him. I could see shapes in it. Several shapes. Very still shapes, pressed close to the glass.
"You asked me something at the tree farm," I said. "Who plans my Christmas."
"I remember."
"I said nobody."
"I remember that too." He reached into his coat and took out a folded sheet of yellow paper. My paper. My legal pad. He must have taken it off my counter on Sunday night. At the top, in square, careful handwriting, it said: JUNE LOGISTICS. Underlined twice.
Below it was a list.
Breakfast somewhere with good pancakes. A tree for her apartment, which doesn't have one, which is a crime. A real first date. Gloves, several pairs, one for every car and coat. The last song. Ask her properly this time.
I read it twice. The letters went blurry the second time.
"I'm not asking you to marry me," Nick said quietly. "I want to be clear about that. The ring was my grandmother's, and you can keep it on or put it in a drawer, and either way it's yours. I'm asking for the date. A real one. As myself. All the names." He paused. "Nicholas Wilde. I'm thirty-five. I run a freight company, badly, apparently. I'm very good with dishwashers. I've never had a family Christmas where nobody checked their phone. And I would like to stand up at your parents' table tonight and not be pretending."
I took the ring out of my pocket. He watched me, very still, braced for it.
I put it back on my finger.
Then I took the pie box out of his hands, set it carefully on the porch railing, because Lou would never forgive either of us, and I took two fistfuls of his good wool coat and said yes.
He made a sound, surprised and low, and then his hands came up to frame my face, cold fingers and warm palms, and he rested his forehead against mine like a man who'd waited for the last song. Snow came down on both of us. Somewhere behind the window, muffled through the glass, I heard my sister shriek and my father start to cry.
When we broke apart, he rested his forehead against mine. His breath clouded between us.
"For the record," he said, a little unsteadily, "that wasn't on the list."
"Write it in," I said. "Underline it."
The front door banged open. My father stood in it, wiping his eyes with a dish towel, the house roaring with light and noise behind him.
"Are you two coming in or not?" he shouted. "Your grandmother's already into the pie!"
Nick looked down at the porch railing. The pie box was open. A fork was missing. Somewhere in the house, Lou cackled.
He laughed then. Really laughed, head back, the first time I'd ever heard it, a big surprised sound that rolled out into the snow on Larkin Street. Then he took my hand in his cold one, laced our fingers together, and looked at the open door the way you'd look at the start of something long.
"After you," said Nicholas Wilde.
And for the first time in a year, I walked into Christmas Eve not knowing exactly how it would go.