Cover of The Island of Second Chances

The Island of Second Chances

Read the story

13 chapters · 15797 words · Read 0 times

Midnight Mass AU. This is after the events of the “angel” dying and freeing everyone from its blood influence. In which Riley and Father Paul, who is canonically younger now and free of the angel’s influence, are actually dating and in love with each other. It’s an open secret, where no one really talks about it but they all know and pretty much support them. Bev Keane is an insufferable bitch about it and Erin is Riley’s best friend who loves to have her friend and his secret amour over for lunch sometimes. Riley’s dad and mom are just happy for him, and Paul is always welcome over for dinner and movie nights. Hell, Sarah Gunning, Paul’s biological daughter who is suspiciously older than him, reconciled after learning the truth of the monster and they have a happy time chatting and getting to know each other.

Chapter 5: A Promise Sealed in Silk and Spend

The sun painted the bedroom in stripes of pale gold. Riley woke with Paul’s hair tickling his nose, the warm, sleeping weight of him a comfort so profound it ached. He carefully extracted his arm from beneath Paul’s neck and reached for his phone.

From the bed, a sleepy, graveled voice mumbled, “No.”

Riley smiled, dialing. “Yes.” He listened to the ring, his other hand sliding beneath the sheets to rest on the gentle, undeniable swell of Paul’s abdomen. It was softer this morning, but still there, a testament to yesterday’s relentless claiming.

Bev answered with her usual clipped efficiency. “St. Patrick’s rectory.”

“Bev, it’s Riley again.”

A heavy sigh traveled through the line. “How’s the patient?”

“Worse, I’m afraid.” Riley’s fingers stroked the curve of Paul’s belly. “Fever spiked again last night. Real bad chills. He’s just… wiped out. I think he’s gonna need the rest of the week, just to be safe.”

“The whole week? Riley, Sunday is–”

“I know what Sunday is. But he can’t lead mass if he’s delirious and coughing, can he? Doctor’s orders. Sort of.” He met Paul’s now-open eyes. Paul was glaring, a faint line of disapproval between his brows. Riley grinned, unrepentant. “I’ll keep you updated. Thanks, Bev.” He hung up.

“You’re a terrible liar,” Paul whispered, but the protest was weak. His body was already shifting, seeking Riley’s touch.

“I’m not lying. You are sick. Sick for my cock.” Riley threw the covers back. The morning air was cool on their skin. Paul’s body was a map of yesterday—love bites on his thighs, the faint red marks of Riley’s grip on his hips. His belly, that beautiful roundness, was more prominent without the sheets. “Now, get up. I have something for you.”

What he had was a box, laid at the foot of the bed. Paul sat up, curiosity replacing his faux-annoyance. He lifted the lid, and a soft, almost inaudible sound escaped him. Nestled inside was pure, glossy pink satin. A nightgown, thin and delicate with spaghetti straps, and matching panties, little more than a scrap of silk.

“Put it on,” Riley said, his voice low. He was already hard, his cock standing thick against his stomach.

Paul’s hands trembled slightly as he lifted the nightgown. The fabric whispered as he pulled it over his head. It settled against his skin like a blush, clinging to the slopes of his breasts, skimming the pronounced curve of his stomach. The dark, berry-sized circles of his nipples pushed against the thin satin, rigid and obscene. The panties he slid on, but they did nothing to conceal the fullness beneath.

“Jesus,” Riley breathed. The sight was devastating. The feminine pink, the vulnerable softness of the gown, contrasted violently with the raw, sexual reality of Paul’s body—the used cunt, the fucked-out belly, the tits that looked heavy and ready to nurse. It short-circuited Riley’s higher brain. He crossed the room in two strides.

He didn’t kiss him. He grabbed a handful of the satin at Paul’s chest and tore it down the middle. The rending sound was loud in the quiet room. Paul gasped, his eyes wide, as the ruined garment parted, exposing his chest. Riley’s mouth was on a nipple immediately, sucking the thick, engorged bud deep, biting down with careful teeth.

Paul cried out, his hands flying to Riley’s head. “Fuck! Riley, please…”

Riley switched to the other nipple, lavishing it with the same brutal attention, his hand shoving the pink panties aside. He didn’t bother with preamble. He pushed two fingers into Paul’s cunt, which was already slick and loose from yesterday. He scissored them, feeling the incredible heat, the soft, swollen walls.

“Still so open,” Riley groaned against his tit. “Still so full of me.” He withdrew his fingers, slick and shining, and guided his cock to Paul’s entrance. He looked into Paul’s eyes. “You’re taking me. All day. Every time I get hard, which is gonna be always. You’re gonna drip my cum until you can’t walk straight.”

He pushed in. It was a smooth, deep invasion, his size stretching Paul exquisitely, filling the emptied space from the night. Paul’s head fell back, a broken whine tearing from his throat as Riley seated himself to the hilt, his balls pressed against Paul’s ass.

Riley fucked him against the edge of the bed, a steady, pounding rhythm. The torn pink satin fluttered with each thrust. Riley gripped Paul’s rounded belly, feeling the depth of his penetration through the soft wall of Paul’s stomach. “Look at you,” he rasped. “Look at how you’re meant to be. Pinned and full. My pretty wife in her pretty pink rags.”

The words unlocked something in Paul. His moans became cries, then sobs. “Don’t stop, don’t stop, please, I need it, I need it—” He was babbling, his body bowing towards Riley’s, his hands clutching anywhere they could find purchase.

Riley felt the tightening coil in his gut. He drove in harder, faster, the wet slap of their coupling echoing off the walls. “You gonna come for me, baby? Gonna come all over this cock that’s gonna knock you up?”

Paul nodded frantically, tears streaming down his face. His orgasm hit him like a seizure, his cunt milking Riley in violent, rhythmic clenches, his whole body shaking. The intensity of it triggered Riley’s own release. He roared, slamming home and burying himself as deep as he could go, pumping wave after wave of hot seed into Paul’s waiting depths. He felt Paul’s belly tighten further under his hand, distending slightly with the new flood.

They collapsed onto the bed, Riley still inside him. Paul was a trembling, crying mess, slick with sweat and tears, his leaking nipples peaked against the torn satin. Riley kissed his temple, his cheeks, tasting salt. “Shhh, it’s okay. You’re so good. You take it so perfect.”

He didn’t pull out. He rolled them over so Paul was on top, impaled, and began to move again, a slow, grinding roll of his hips. Paul whimpered, over-sensitive, but pushed down, taking him deeper.

The day dissolved into a sweaty, satin-streaked haze. Riley took him on the rug, the pink fabric rucked up around Paul’s waist. He bent him over the kitchen table, the cool wood against Paul’s cheek, and fucked him until the dishes rattled. Each orgasm Riley ripped from Paul left him more incoherent—a drooling, pleading creature whose only vocabulary was Riley’s name and sobbed please.

In the afternoon, sprawled on the living room couch, Paul lay with his head in Riley’s lap, Riley’s softening cock still resting against his swollen lips. Riley traced the tight curve of Paul’s stomach, now round and firm, packed tight with successive loads.

“By the end of the week,” Riley said, his voice quiet with certainty, “you’re gonna be pregnant. I can feel it. My seed’s gonna take root in you. You’re gonna blossom.”

Paul turned his head, nuzzling Riley’s thigh. He was too spent for words, but his eyes, full of exhausted adoration, said everything.

“We’ll get married,” Riley continued, his dream a low hum in the quiet room. “Simple. On the beach. Just our family. You’ll wear white, not pink. You’ll have a little bump, just starting to show.” He could see it. The wind in Paul’s long hair, the simple gold band, the smell of salt and cake. “I’ll be your husband. I’ll protect you. I’ll come home to you. Every day.”

Paul found his voice, a raw scrape. “Yes. To all of it. Forever.”

Riley sank down to kiss him, a slow, deep promise. When they parted, he was hard again. Paul sighed, a happy, broken sound, and opened his legs. The ruined pink silk was soaked, stuck to his skin. Riley pushed it aside and entered him once more, a seamless continuation of their vow. There were no more words. Just the slow, relentless push and pull, a physical covenant spoken in sweat and seed and the unshakable certainty that this, here, was their forever.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI