Cover of The Island of Second Chances

The Island of Second Chances

Read the story

13 chapters · 15797 words · Read 0 times

Midnight Mass AU. This is after the events of the “angel” dying and freeing everyone from its blood influence. In which Riley and Father Paul, who is canonically younger now and free of the angel’s influence, are actually dating and in love with each other. It’s an open secret, where no one really talks about it but they all know and pretty much support them. Bev Keane is an insufferable bitch about it and Erin is Riley’s best friend who loves to have her friend and his secret amour over for lunch sometimes. Riley’s dad and mom are just happy for him, and Paul is always welcome over for dinner and movie nights. Hell, Sarah Gunning, Paul’s biological daughter who is suspiciously older than him, reconciled after learning the truth of the monster and they have a happy time chatting and getting to know each other.

Chapter 8: The Confirmation

The ferry ride to the mainland felt different. The churn of the water under the hull, the shriek of the gulls, the salt spray—it was all the same, but the silence between them was a live wire. They sat on a bench on the leeward side, shoulders pressed together, Riley’s arm draped around Paul. He wasn’t reading. Paul wasn’t gazing thoughtfully at the horizon. They were just holding on, watching the island shrink into a smudge of green and grey, their future a palpable, terrifying knot in the air between them.

Riley drove the borrowed truck off the ferry ramp, the tires humming on the wet asphalt. “You ready?” he asked, his voice rough.

Paul’s hand found his knee, squeezed. “No,” he said, honest and simple. “But let’s go anyway.”

The clinic was in a converted Victorian house on a tree-lined street, not in the sterile medical complex. A discreet sign read “Haven Family Health & Wellness.” Rainbow flags and transgender pride banners hung in the windows, interspersed with posters about reproductive justice. Riley felt a tension he hadn’t named uncoil in his shoulders.

The waiting room was warm, quiet. A young person with purple hair typed behind the reception desk, offering a smile that didn’t demand anything. The air smelled of lemongrass and clean linen. They filled out paperwork together, Paul’s elegant script next to Riley’s blocky print. Reason for visit: Possible pregnancy. Paul’s pen hovered over the line for Patient Name. He wrote, firmly, Paul Hill.

A door opened. “Paul? Riley?” The doctor was maybe fifty, with a halo of silver curls and a cardigan covered in embroidered astrophysica flowers over soft linen trousers. Their eyes were kind, crinkled at the corners. “I’m Dr. Callahan. Come on back.”

The exam room was bright, with a huge window overlooking a garden. A model of the pelvic floor sat next to a jar of condoms and a stack of pamphlets about queer family planning.

“So,” Dr. Callahan said, sitting on a rolling stool and glancing at their chart. “You’ve had some feelings that suggest pregnancy. Tell me about that.”

Paul did, his voice low but clear. He talked about the sensitivity, the strange fullness, the sharpening of senses. Riley listened, adding nothing, his hand a steady weight on Paul’s back. He saw the doctor’s eyes, intelligent and non-judgmental, taking it all in.

“Given your unique physiological history,” Dr. Callahan said, their tone purely clinical and warm, “standard urine tests might be less reliable. I’d like to do a blood draw today—it’s the gold standard—and if you’re comfortable, a quick transvaginal ultrasound. We might be able to see a gestational sac if you’re far enough along. How does that sound?”

Paul looked at Riley, then nodded. “Yes. Please.”

The blood draw was quick, a tiny vial of dark ruby filled and labelled. The ultrasound was more intimate. Paul lay on the table, a sheet over his lap, his knees bent. Riley stood by his head, one hand gripping Paul’s. Dr. Callahan explained each step, the warm gel, the slender wand. The screen was a grey, static-filled mystery.

Then the doctor moved the wand, adjusted a dial. A soft, rushing sound filled the room—a swift, rhythmic whoosh-whoosh-whoosh.

“That’s your heartbeat, Paul,” Dr. Callahan murmured.

Then they focused, zoomed in. In the center of the grey chaos, a small, dark, circular hole appeared. Nestled within it, a tiny, bean-shaped smudge of white.

“And that,” Dr. Callahan said, their professional calm breaking into a wide, unmistakable grin, “is a gestational sac. And that little flicker right there… that’s your baby’s heartbeat.”

The world stopped. The sound filled the room, a tiny, galloping horse, a frantic, perfect drum. Whoosh-whoosh-whoosh.

Paul’s breath left him in a shuddering gasp. A sound ripped from Riley’s chest, a sob he didn’t recognize as his own. He dropped his forehead to Paul’s, their tears mixing. He could feel Paul shaking beneath him.

“You’re pregnant,” Dr. Callahan said softly, gently removing the wand. “About six weeks along, by the looks of it. Everything looks perfect.”

They were crying then, properly, messy and unchecked. Riley pulled Paul up, heedless of the gel, and crushed him in an embrace so tight he feared he might break him. Paul clung back, his face buried in Riley’s neck, his shoulders heaving. They were saying nothing, just holding on, the tiny, relentless heartbeat still echoing in their minds.

“I have a baby,” Paul whispered, wet and incredulous, against Riley’s skin. “We have a baby.”

Riley just nodded, his voice gone, kissing Paul’s temple, his cheek, his tears.

Dr. Callahan gave them a moment, then handed them a box of tissues and a printout of the ultrasound image. The little white bean, the tiny sac. “Congratulations,” they said, their own eyes bright. “You’re going to be amazing parents.”

In the truck, the ultrasound photo sat on the dashboard like a holy relic. Paul kept touching it, tracing the outline with a trembling finger. He was radiant, weeping and laughing in the same breath. “We have to call everyone. Right now. Your dad. Your parents. Erin. Sarah—oh God, Riley, Sarah’s going to be a—”

“Wait,” Riley said, starting the engine. His heart was a jackhammer. The ring box was a lead weight in his jacket pocket. He’d been thumbing the corner of it the whole drive over, the velvety texture now worn smooth with his anxiety.

“Wait?” Paul turned to him, his beautiful face blotchy and confused.

“Just for tonight,” Riley said, pulling into traffic. “Let’s… let’s keep it just ours for one more night. Let’s stay. Get a hotel. Have a dinner, just you and me. A date. To celebrate us.” He glanced over, pleading. “Then tomorrow, we can invite everyone. Your dad, my folks, Erin, Sarah. We’ll have them all over for dinner and tell them together. A proper… announcement.”

Paul stared at him, the joy still brimming over. He sniffed, a slow, understanding smile spreading through his tears. “You’re being romantic.”

“I’m being selfish,” Riley corrected, his throat tight. “I want you to myself for one more night before we share you with the whole world.”

Paul’s expression softened. He reached over, his hand covering Riley’s on the gear shift. “Okay,” he whispered. Then a giggle burst out of him, watery and pure. “A date. I’m pregnant and we’re going on a date.”

Riley laughed too, the sound ragged with relief and overwhelming love. “Yeah. We are.”

He booked a room at a small, quiet inn overlooking the harbor. They walked along the waterfront, Paul pointing out absurd things like, “That seal is probably a father,” and “That boat looks like it has good schools.” They ate at a bistro where Paul ordered two desserts and ate most of both, moaning about the chocolate tart with a bliss that was almost indecent.

Back in the hotel room, with the city lights glittering on the dark water, they lay in bed. Paul’s back was against Riley’s chest, Riley’s palm splayed possessively over the firm, subtle curve of Paul’s lower belly. The ultrasound photo was on the nightstand.

“Today was the best day of my life,” Paul murmured, already half-asleep.

Riley kissed his shoulder. “Mine too.” It was true. Even with all that had come before, the horror and the grace, this quiet joy eclipsed it all.

He waited until Paul’s breathing evened out into sleep. Then, carefully, he slid his hand into his jacket pocket, which hung on the bedpost. His fingers closed around the small, square box. He didn’t take it out. He just held it in the dark, feeling its shape, its promise.

Tomorrow. He would ask tomorrow, with their people around them, with this new, miraculous life humming secretly between them. He had to get through one more day of holding this joy inside. It felt like trying to contain the sun.

He tucked the box away, pulled Paul closer, and listened to the gentle sound of his breath, matching it to the memory of that galloping heartbeat. The future was a room, just up ahead, waiting for them to walk in. He just had to open the door.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI