Chapter 2: Hypothetically Speaking
She found him at the far end of the jetty at half past seven, drinking coffee out of a tin mug and watching the seals as if they owed him money.
"Were you in my room last night?"
Gideon turned. He looked at her face, then at the notebook clutched to her chest, then at her red wellies, which she had put on the wrong feet in her hurry. His eyebrows rose.
"No," he said. "Were you in mine?"
That stopped her. "Why would I be in yours?"
"Because when I woke up, the door was open, and my notes from yesterday afternoon were on the floor." He reached into his coat and took out a black notebook, the expensive kind with an elastic strap. He opened it and turned it towards her. One page had been torn out. Neatly, at the spine. "Second session. Everything she told me about August."
Nell stared at the ragged edge. Then she opened her own notebook and held it up beside his. Two missing pages, side by side, torn out by the same careful hand.
"There was a footprint," she said. "A big one. Wet."
Gideon looked down at his own feet. He was wearing sheepskin slippers, slightly too small, with a pattern of reindeer on them.
"Morag's late husband's," he said, with dignity. "My boots are drying by the range. They've been there since dinner. Ask her."
Nell did ask her. Morag, who was kneading bread with the violence of a woman settling a grudge, confirmed that Mr Rook's boots had been by the range all night, that the doors of Fiadh House were never locked because who would lock them, and that nobody else was on the island except the four of them, Scarpia, and the birdwatcher.
"What birdwatcher?" said Nell and Gideon at the same time.
"Came over last Tuesday. Hired one of those grey rubber boats out of Tarbert. Says he's counting corncrakes." Morag slapped the dough down. "He's camping in the old bothy at the north end. Fearghas didn't bring him, and Fearghas has opinions about that."
"Has anyone seen him count a corncrake?"
Morag looked at Gideon over the bread with something like approval.
"Not so I've noticed," she said.
For four days after that, they were rivals.
It was easier that way. Nell took her mornings in the drawing room with the Dame and Scarpia and a pot of tea strong enough to strip varnish. She asked her questions the way she always did, the easy one first and then the real one, and the Dame answered with performances: the night in Vienna when the curtain caught fire, the duke who proposed in a lift, the soprano in Milan who put salt in her throat spray. Matteo Vanni came into every story eventually, like weather. And every time he did, Catriona Bell called him something new and terrible, and every time, for a second, she smiled.
In the afternoons Nell sat in her room and wrote. She could hear Gideon in the drawing room below, his low voice, the Dame's laugh. Once she heard the Dame singing, just a phrase, unaccompanied, and she sat with her pen lifted and her eyes closed until it ended.
At dinner, he said nothing that could get either of them sent home. Neither did she. They passed the salt with extreme courtesy, like two diplomats from countries about to go to war.
But the house was small, and the island was smaller. She met him on the stairs. She met him in the kitchen at midnight, both of them looking for oatcakes. She met him on the beach at dawn on the third day, sitting on a rock writing, and he looked up and said, "You ask the second question," as though they had been in the middle of a conversation.
"What?"
"In interviews. You ask one easy question so they relax, and then you ask the second one, and that's the real one. I've read your books. The best line in every chapter is the answer to a second question."
She stood there in the wind with no idea what to say.
"It's a good technique," he said, and went back to writing, as if he hadn't just handed her the nicest thing anyone had said about her work in a year.
On the fifth day, Nell walked to the north end of the island to look at the bothy, and the sky fell on her.
It came in from the west the way Hebridean weather does, without warning or apology: the light went yellow, then grey, then the rain arrived horizontally with hail in it. She was halfway across the headland with nowhere to go. Through the downpour she could see the bothy, dark and empty, its door padlocked. Below it, on the shingle of a little cove, crouched a stone boathouse with a tin roof.
She ran for it, slipped, and was hauled upright by the elbow before she hit the rocks.
"You followed me," she gasped, as Gideon dragged her through the boathouse door and slammed it behind them.
"I was here first," he said, breathing hard. Rain ran off the end of his crooked nose. "I came to look at the bothy. Great minds."
The boathouse smelled of tar and old rope. Light came through a single salt-crusted window. An ancient wooden dinghy sat upside down on trestles in the middle of the floor, and on its keel, painted in faded blue, was a name. Nell wiped the glass of her spectacles on her jumper and leaned closer.
Tosca.
They looked at each other.
The hail roared on the tin roof. Outside, the sea was the colour of slate. Fearghas would not be crossing today, and nobody would be walking back across that headland for at least two hours. Nell sat down on a coil of rope, shivering, and after a moment Gideon took off his long black coat and dropped it over her shoulders without a word.
It was warm and smelled of woodsmoke. She pulled it tighter.
"Thank you," she said.
"I'm not being kind. If you get hypothermia, I win by default. It would look terrible in the trade press."
"Of course."
He sat down on an upturned crate opposite her and looked at the dinghy for a long time. Then he said, carefully, as if testing the ice on a pond, "The agreement says we can't discuss anything she's told us."
"I know what it says."
"It doesn't say anything about hypotheticals."
Nell looked at him. He looked back, completely straight-faced.
"That," she said, "is the most lawyerly thing I've ever heard."
"I read every footnote. There isn't one about hypotheticals." He leaned his elbows on his knees. "Hypothetically. Suppose there was a woman who lived on an island. And suppose that every August, for many years, she told her housekeeper to make up the blue room, and a man came over from the mainland in his own boat. He stayed a fortnight. He painted. He was never called by his name. And he once painted the ceiling of a certain glass room with stars, because she said she couldn't sleep without them." He paused. "Hypothetically."
Nell's heart was beating very fast.
"Hypothetically," she said slowly, "suppose there was a woman who sang at a festival in Austria every summer. Late July to mid-August, every year, opposite the same man. And suppose she and that man had a famous public fight there, every single season, so famous that photographers waited at the stage door just to watch her throw things at him." She swallowed. "And suppose that, whenever she talks about him, she calls him something dreadful, and then she smiles."
The rain hammered on the roof. Gideon had gone very still.
"The festival ends," he said. "Mid-August."
"And then he comes to the island. In his own boat."
"And nobody suspects a thing," Gideon said quietly, "because the whole of Europe has just watched her throw a shoe at his head."
Neither of them said the name. Neither of them needed to.
The hail eased to rain. The rain eased to drizzle. Neither of them moved to leave.
"Why do you do it?" Nell asked him eventually. "Ghostwriting. You hate memoirs. You told an entire panel at the Hay festival that every memoir is a lie the subject paid for."
"You were there?"
"Third row. I threw a grape at you. You didn't notice."
Something moved at the corner of his mouth. Then it went away again, and he looked at the dinghy.
"My father wrote a memoir," he said. "Well. Someone wrote it for him. It was about what a devoted family man he was. Long walks with his son on the South Downs. Bedtime stories. It sold very well." He turned his tin mug, which he had somehow carried all the way from the house, round and round in his hands. "He left when I was very young. I don't remember a single walk. So, yes. I think people pay to have their lives rewritten. And I'm very good at it. At least I know I'm lying."
Nell looked at him, at the bent head and the crooked nose and the careful hands, and felt something she had not expected to feel about Gideon Rook, which was the urge to put her arms around him.
She didn't. She said, instead, "I don't think they're lies. Most of them."
"No?"
"I think they're letters. To someone who isn't there anymore. People tell me the truth by accident, in the bits they think don't matter. My goalkeeper talked for six hours about saves and trophies, and the only time he cried was about his dad's runner beans." She pulled his coat tighter. "That's the book. Not the trophies. That's always the book."
He was looking at her now. Not the sharp, measuring look from the slipway. Something slower.
"I read it twice," he said.
"What?"
"The goalkeeper. After the party. I read it twice. The allotment chapter is the best thing I read that year." He looked away, at the window. "Competent sentiment was a lie. I was annoyed, because I'd been offered that book and turned it down, and you'd made it better than I would have."
Nell opened her mouth and found she had nothing whatsoever to say.
Through the salt-crusted window, a movement caught her eye. She stood up, his coat sliding off one shoulder, and wiped the glass with her sleeve.
On the far side of the cove, at the foot of the headland, a man in a grey anorak was climbing into a grey rubber boat. He had binoculars round his neck and a long-lensed camera in one hand. In the other he carried a cardboard tube, the kind used for posters, or plans, or rolled-up papers.
The engine coughed into life. The boat swung away south, towards Harris, and was gone into the drizzle.
"Corncrakes," said Gideon, beside her, very softly.
It was dark by the time they got back, soaked to the knees. Morag met them at the kitchen door with towels and a face like a closed book.
"Mr Hugo Lennox rang," she said. "He's coming over first thing tomorrow, with a lawyer. He says he has some documents that concern the memoir." She looked from one to the other. "And she wants you."
Dame Catriona was standing at the top of the main staircase, in black, with every ring on and Scarpia at her feet. She looked down at the two of them dripping on her flagstones, at Gideon's coat around Nell's shoulders, and her face gave away nothing at all.
"One of you," she said, "has broken my agreement."
Neither of them breathed.
"The music room. Nine o'clock tomorrow. Both of you." She turned to go, and then turned back. "And Mr Rook. Do take your coat back from Miss Fairley. She looks as though she's been eaten by a crow."