Cover of The Secret Aria

Romance

The Secret Aria

Read the story

3 chapters · 5898 words · Read 0 times

A rivals to lovers romance with a mystery at its heart, set on a storm-lashed Hebridean island. Warm-hearted ghostwriter Nell Fairley and award-winning cynic Gideon Rook are both flown to Eilean Fiadh to audition for the same job: writing the memoir of Dame Catriona Bell, the reclusive opera legend who walked off the stage at the height of her fame. The Dame tells each of them a different half of her life, and binds both with the same strict confidentiality agreement. Then pages start vanishing, a love duet plays in a locked room at night, and the rivals begin trading secrets they swore to keep. Rivals to lovers, forced proximity, slow burn. Whose secret is buried on this island, and who is trying to keep it there?

Characters

  • Dame Catriona Bell — A retired Scottish soprano who left the stage abruptly in 1998 and has lived on Eilean Fiadh ever since. She is finally ready to tell her story, but only in halves.
  • Fearghas — The boatman who runs the only crossing to Eilean Fiadh.
  • Gideon Rook — The most admired ghostwriter in London, whose anonymous political memoir won a major prize that everyone knows was really his. He believes every memoir is a lie the subject paid for, and he reads every footnote.
  • Hugo Lennox — The Dame's stepson, heir to her late husband's estate and the rights to her recordings. He would very much prefer the memoir never be written.
  • Morag MacAskill — The Dame's housekeeper of thirty years, who knows more than she says and says very little.
  • Nell Fairley — A ghostwriter of celebrity memoirs who believes every life story is a love letter the subject never sent. She has spent three years resenting Gideon Rook for one careless remark, and now has to beat him for the job of her career.

Chapter 3: The Duet

Nobody went into the music room without Dame Catriona. At nine o'clock the next morning, she opened the door herself and stood aside to let them in.

It was like stepping into the inside of a lantern. Glass on three sides, the sea beyond it grey and silver and endless, a grand piano with its lid closed, an old record player on a walnut cabinet. And above them, across the whole ceiling, someone had painted the night sky. Not in the vague way of hotel ceilings, but precisely: the Plough, Cassiopeia, the long smudge of the Milky Way, every star placed by a hand that had looked up at this exact sky and loved it.

Nell heard Gideon breathe out beside her.

"Sit," said the Dame.

They didn't. They stood side by side in front of her like two people waiting to be sentenced, and before Nell could stop herself, she said, "It was me."

At precisely the same moment, Gideon said, "It was me."

They looked at each other. Dame Catriona looked at them both. And then, to Nell's astonishment, she threw back her head and laughed, a great ringing laugh that went up into the painted stars and seemed to stay there.

"Both of you," she said, wiping her eyes with a ringed finger. "Thank God. I was beginning to think I'd chosen badly."

"You wanted us to break it," Gideon said slowly.

"Of course I wanted you to break it. Why else would I tell you each half?" She lowered herself onto the piano stool and arranged her kaftan. "It took two people to keep this secret for forty years, Mr Rook. I wasn't going to hand it to one person to tell. I needed someone who would find the heart of it." She nodded at Nell. "And someone who would never stop poking at the parts that didn't add up." She nodded at Gideon. "And I needed to know you could trust each other, because I'm about to trust you both with the only thing I've got left."

She stood, crossed to the record player and lifted the lid.

"His name was Matteo," she said. "You'll have guessed that. I slapped him at La Scala in our first season together because he trod on my train on purpose, and I meant every bit of that slap. The second season, he apologised. The third season, I married Rupert Lennox, because Rupert owned my contracts and my recording rights and could end my career with one telephone call, and he wanted a wife who looked well in photographs." She took a record from its plain white sleeve and held it by the edges. "By the fourth season, Matteo and I were in love. And Rupert would have ruined him. So we gave the newspapers a war instead."

"The shoe," Nell whispered.

"Thrown with great accuracy, to miss." For a moment, the Dame looked very pleased with herself. "Every August, after Salzburg, I came here. Two days later, so did he. He sailed himself over from Uig in a little boat with a tender called Tosca, because he thought that was funny. He painted that ceiling the summer I told him I couldn't sleep." She looked up at it. "In August of 1998, the fog came down in the Minch. He set out anyway. He always set out anyway."

She didn't finish. She didn't have to. Nell felt Gideon's hand brush against hers, and then, without either of them looking, take hold of it.

"I never sang again," said the Dame. "Not one note on a stage. They said it was my nerves." She lowered the needle onto the record. "We made this in this room. He wrote it for me. It is the only copy in the world."

The soprano and the baritone from the night. Young and alive, singing to each other in a glass room by the sea. Nell listened with her eyes stinging and Gideon's hand tight around hers, and when it ended, there was a moment of crackling silence and then a man's voice, warm and amused and very close to the microphone.

"Per Catriona," he said, "che mi odia. Fiadh, agosto."

For Catriona, who hates me.

The Dame lifted the needle.

"There were letters," she said, quite calmly. "Twenty years of them. In a tin in the boathouse. I went down this morning, before you were awake." She turned to them. "The tin is empty."

Hugo Lennox arrived before noon, in a hired launch, in a navy overcoat that had never met weather. The lawyer with him was a thin, tired woman called Ms Achterberg, who looked as though she would rather be anywhere else, and walking up the jetty behind them, carrying a cardboard tube, came the man in the grey anorak.

"Mr Dunbar," Hugo said, as they gathered in the drawing room, "has been very helpful. An expert in rare birds." He turned his signet ring. "Catriona. I won't take up much of your time. I'm told you're writing a book."

"I'm told you're selling my recordings," said the Dame.

"The catalogue. Yes. To a very good label. They plan a beautiful boxed set." He smiled. "They're calling it The Feud. The legendary rivalry, the greatest Tosca and the greatest Scarpia, hating each other across twenty years. It's worth a great deal of money, as long as the story stays the story." He nodded at the tube. "These letters are my father's property, found on my father's island."

"It's my island."

"That," said Ms Achterberg, very quietly, "is not entirely settled."

"Publish anything about Vanni," Hugo said pleasantly, "and I'll sue you for defaming my father's memory. Without these, it's the word of a lonely old woman against forty years of newspapers. With them," he patted the tube, "it's a bonfire. Your choice."

Nell felt her face burn with anger. She opened her mouth. Gideon's hand closed briefly on her wrist under the table, and let go.

"Mr Lennox," Gideon said. He had his black notebook open in front of him and was reading from it in the mild voice of a man checking a train timetable. "You've mentioned forty years of newspapers. I've read most of them. I've also read the company accounts for Lennox Artists Management, which are public. From 1983, your father's company paid a Fleet Street photographer a monthly retainer for exactly four weeks every summer. Salzburg. Every year until 1997." He turned a page. "So the famous shoe photograph was commissioned. By your father. Who knew perfectly well his wife and Signor Vanni weren't enemies, and found it very profitable that everyone thought they were."

The room was silent. Hugo had stopped turning his ring.

"If you sue," Gideon went on, "that goes into evidence. And then your boxed set is called something else."

Ms Achterberg closed her folder.

"Hugo," she said, "I think we should go."

"Those letters—"

"Are on my island," said Dame Catriona, rising. "And you are not. Morag will see you to the jetty."

Hugo went. But he went with the tube under his arm, and Mr Dunbar behind him, and as the launch pulled away into the grey water, Nell stood at the window and watched twenty years of a love story disappear south towards Harris.

That evening, the Dame called them both back to the music room. She did not sit. She stood under the painted stars with her chin up, the way she stood in the portrait above the fire.

"I'm not choosing," she said. "I'm hiring you both. You'll write it together. Miss Fairley will make them weep. Mr Rook will make sure nobody can sue. You will both be paid the full fee, and you will both be very difficult, and I shall enjoy it enormously." She swept to the door and paused. "And for heaven's sake, sort yourselves out. The two of you have been throwing shoes at each other since you got off the boat. I have seen this opera before. I know how the second act goes."

She closed the door behind her.

The sun was going down into the Atlantic. The glass room filled with orange light, and the painted stars were starting to look real.

Nell turned to Gideon. He was standing by the piano, looking at her with an expression she had seen on his face only once before, in the boathouse, when she had talked about the runner beans.

"How did you know?" she asked. "About the photographer. The accounts."

"I didn't, until two this morning. I couldn't sleep." He shrugged. "Company records are very boring. Nobody reads the footnotes."

"Except you."

"Except me."

She took a step towards him. Then another. Her heart was going like Fearghas's engine.

"I'm going to ask you a question," she said. "An easy one first."

The corner of his mouth moved. "I know how you work."

"Are you glad? That we're sharing it."

"Yes." He didn't hesitate. "Ask the second one."

Nell looked up at him, at the crooked nose and the untidy hair and the dark eyes that had been watching her across dinner tables and down staircases and over the top of a black notebook for three weeks.

"The first night," she said. "At dinner. You broke the agreement on purpose. You told me about August when you knew I'd catch it. Why?"

Gideon was quiet for a moment. The last of the sun caught the side of his face.

"Because I'd spent three years wanting to apologise to you," he said, "and I couldn't think of a single way to start a conversation with you that wasn't about salt."

Nell laughed. It came out a little wet. And then she reached up, took a handful of his ridiculous black coat, and kissed him under Matteo Vanni's stars.

He went very still, the way he had in the boathouse, as if he had been handed something precious and was afraid of dropping it. Then his hand came up to the back of her neck, gentle, like a man who reads every page and does not intend to skip a single one.

When they finally broke apart, the room had gone blue with dusk. Somewhere in the house, very faintly, the Dame was singing.

"Hypothetically," Nell said, against his jumper, "if a man had taken twenty years of letters south in a cardboard tube."

"Hypothetically."

"Would a pair of ghostwriters with a boat, a deaf collie and a very good knowledge of company accounts be able to get them back?"

Gideon looked out at the dark water, towards Harris, where a launch had gone and a man with a signet ring thought he had won.

"Fairley," he said, and she could hear him smiling, "I think that's the first chapter."

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI