Cover of Will She or Won't She?

Will She or Won't She?

Read the story

4 chapters · 13125 words · Read 0 times

Candace is fearful of becoming a spinster, until Will comes back into her life. He becomes the object of her ever-growing affection and obsession.

Chapter 1: The Return That Ignites Her Hunger

The dust motes danced in the single shaft of afternoon sun piercing the high library window. Candace Armitage traced a finger along the cracked spine of a particularly worn Regency romance, the scent of decaying paper and old glue thick in her nostrils. Thirty-five. The number echoed in the quiet, a relentless metronome ticking against the silence of the stacks. Spinster. The word felt heavy, woven into the very fabric of her sensible cardigan. She shelved the book with more force than necessary, the thump startlingly loud in the emptiness.

Outside, the sleepy hum of Willow Creek drifted through the heavy oak doors – the distant whine of Mr. Henderson’s lawnmower, the clang of the bell over the diner entrance. Inside, it was just Candace and the ghosts of a thousand stories, none of them hers. She bent to retrieve another stack from the reshelving cart, her long auburn curls escaping their loose bun to brush against her flushed cheek. These were the new arrivals, the lurid covers promising passion and grand adventures she could only devour in stolen moments between organizing the local history section and refereeing arguments over the periodicals.

The bell above the library door jingled, sharp and intrusive. Footsteps echoed on the worn linoleum, firm, confident strides that didn't belong to Mrs. Gable coming for her weekly Agatha Christie fix.

Candace straightened, smoothing her floral skirt automatically. Then she saw him.

Time didn't just stop; it crumpled. Will. Standing just inside the doorway, sunlight haloing his broad shoulders. He looked older, harder lines etched around his eyes, his dark hair shorter, perhaps a touch of grey at the temples. But the aura of restless energy was the same, the faint scent of leather and something indefinably distant – petrol, maybe, or desert air? – hit her senses like a physical blow. He filled the cramped space near the circulation desk, making the towering shelves seem suddenly oppressive.

"Candace." His voice was deeper than she remembered, rougher, a low rumble that vibrated down her spine.

She blinked, clutching the stack of books to her chest like a shield. "Will." Her own voice sounded thin, reedy. "Back in town?"

"Passing through." His gaze swept over her, lingering for a fraction of a second too long on the curve of her hip barely visible above the stack she held. It felt like being touched. "Place hasn't changed much." He gestured vaguely at the dusty shelves.

"Small towns," she managed, shifting the books. One slipped from the pile. She fumbled, her fingers clumsy, sending another two tumbling towards the floor with soft thuds. Mortification burned her cheeks. "Oh, damn it!"

He moved faster than she could react, bending smoothly to catch the falling books before they hit the ground. His large, work-roughened hand brushed against hers as he retrieved the last one, a particularly steamy cover featuring a half-naked Highlander. The contact was electric, a jolt that travelled straight up her arm and settled low in her belly. He held the book for a beat, his thumb stroking the embossed title absently, his gaze fixed on hers. Not mocking, exactly. Intense. Assessing.

"Still enjoy the classics, I see," he said, his voice a low murmur that seemed to bypass her ears and resonate directly in her bloodstream. He offered the book back.

Her fingers trembled as she took it, their touch lingering again. His skin was warm, dry. Calloused. The scent of him – leather, sun, man – was overwhelming. "Just... processing returns," she stammered, stacking the books back haphazardly. "Can I... help you find something?"

He leaned a hip against the counter, invading her space effortlessly. His eyes, a startling green flecked with gold, held hers. There was a challenge there, an old spark she thought long extinguished. "Recommendation? Been a while since I read anything that wasn't a technical manual."

Her mind went utterly blank. Every title she’d ever known evaporated. Her carefully curated world of fictional heroes dissolved into the reality of Will’s presence, the sheer, overwhelming maleness of him. "Um... what...genre?" she managed, her throat tight.

He shrugged, a slow roll of powerful shoulders under the worn denim jacket. "Surprise me. Something... engaging." A ghost of a smile touched his lips. "Something worth getting lost in."

Her pulse hammered against her ribs. She scanned the shelves behind him blindly, then turned towards the romance section she’d just been tending. Her legs felt unsteady. She walked towards the familiar aisle, acutely aware of his eyes following her, tracing the sway of her hips beneath the modest skirt. The silence between them was thick, charged, broken only by the soft shuffle of her sensible shoes on the floor.

He followed her into the narrow canyon of shelves. The space, already dim, seemed to shrink further. She could feel the heat radiating from his body just inches away. She stopped, ran a shaky finger along the spines. "Here," she said, pulling out a thick historical saga known for its explicit scenes. She turned, thrusting it towards him. "This is...popular."

He took it, his fingers brushing hers again. He didn't look at the book. He looked at her. His gaze dropped to her lips, then back to her eyes, holding her captive. The air crackled. The dust motes seemed to dance faster. The silence wasn't quiet anymore; it was a roaring in her ears, a pressure building.

"Candace..." he began, his voice barely above a whisper, rough as gravel.

The name on his lips felt like a caress she hadn't felt in a decade. Her carefully constructed wall of resignation, the quiet acceptance of her spinster fate, trembled. Years of daydreams, fueled by the very books lining these shelves, surged forward – not the chaste kisses of Regency beaus, but raw, hungry fantasies she’d barely dared acknowledge. He was here. Real. And he was looking at her like that.

She didn't think. The stack of books slipped from her grasp, hitting the floor with a series of muffled thuds, forgotten. She stepped forward, closing the tiny distance between them. Her hand, acting of its own volition, came up to press flat against the hard plane of his chest, feeling the rapid, powerful beat of his heart through the thin cotton of his shirt. His heat scorched her palm.

He sucked in a sharp breath. His free hand shot out, not to push her away, but to grab her hip, fingers digging in with possessive pressure. The book dropped from his other hand, joining hers on the floor.

"You sure, Candy?" His voice was strained, thick with the same hunger she felt clawing its way up her throat. That old nickname, unused for years, sent another shiver through her.

In answer, she stretched up, her body arching towards his, and pressed her lips to his. It wasn't tentative. It was desperate. A dam bursting. A decade of pent-up want exploding in a single, clumsy, consuming kiss.

He groaned, a deep, visceral sound that vibrated against her mouth. His hand on her hip slid around to the small of her back, crushing her against him. His other hand tangled in her auburn curls, dislodging hairpins that pinged softly on the linoleum. His kiss wasn't gentle. It was demanding, relentless, his tongue sweeping past her lips, claiming her mouth with a raw urgency that stole her breath.

She matched him, kiss for hungry kiss. Her hands fisted in the soft denim of his jacket, pulling him impossibly closer. He tasted faintly of coffee and something elemental, something wild. The scent of old paper and dust was obliterated by the smell of him, of sweat and leather and pure, potent male. The world narrowed to the hard press of his body against hers, the scrape of his stubble against her cheek, the desperate slide of tongues, the frantic beat of her own pulse echoing his.

His hand left her hair, sliding down her neck, over the collar of her cardigan, rough fingertips brushing the exposed skin of her collarbone. She gasped into his mouth, arching into the touch. His fingers slipped lower, fumbling with the buttons of her blouse beneath the cardigan. One popped open. Then another. Cool air brushed her skin, followed instantly by the searing heat of his palm as he cupped her breast, still encased in her sensible cotton bra.

"Oh, god, Will," she moaned, breaking the kiss to gasp for air, her head falling back against the unforgiving shelving unit behind her. The hard wood dug into her spine, a sharp counterpoint to the molten heat flooding her veins.

He didn't pause. His mouth trailed hot, open-mouthed kisses down the column of her throat, his teeth scraping lightly over her pulse point. His thumb found her nipple through the thin fabric of her bra, rubbing in a slow, maddening circle. She whimpered, her hips rocking instinctively against the hard ridge she could feel pressing against her thigh through their clothes. The sheer, overwhelming reality of it – Will, here, touching her like this, after so long, in the middle of her library – was dizzying. It shattered her inhibitions, fueled by years of lonely longing.

"Fuck, Candy," he growled against her skin, his breath hot. "Still so sweet. Still so fucking

The rough pad of his thumb circled her nipple again, hard enough through the thin cotton to make her gasp. "Always knew you'd feel like this," he rasped, his mouth hot and wet against the frantic pulse in her throat. His other hand slid down her spine, fingers digging possessively into the curve of her ass, pulling her tighter against the undeniable hardness straining against his jeans. It pressed insistently against her belly, a thick, solid promise that sent liquid heat pooling low in her own body. "Fuck, Candy. Been dreamin’ about this."

"Screw dreaming," she breathed, the words ragged, torn from somewhere deep and primal. Years of polite librarian smiles, prim cardigans, and silent evenings dissolved under the sheer, overwhelming avalanche of sensation. She yanked at the snap of his jeans, fingers fumbling clumsily. "Show me. Now."

A harsh chuckle vibrated against her skin. His hand left her breast, leaving the nipple aching and tight, and covered hers. "Easy, sweet thing." He guided her fingers, popping the button free, dragging the zipper down with a harsh, metallic rasp that echoed obscenely in the dusty quiet. The sound electrified her. He shoved the denim and worn cotton boxers down his hips just far enough. His cock sprang free, thick and heavy, rigidly erect, the flushed head already slick. The musky scent of pure male arousal hit her, thick and primal, drowning out the old paper smell completely.

He didn't ask. Didn't hesitate. His hand shoved her skirt up roughly, bunching the floral fabric around her waist. His fingers hooked into the elastic waistband of her sensible cotton panties, jerking them down her thighs in one savage motion. Cool air brushed her exposed core, instantly replaced by the scorching heat of his palm pressing hard against her mound. She cried out, arching off the bookshelf, her head cracking against a thick volume titled Botany of the Eastern Seaboard. The pain was distant, irrelevant.

"Jesus, you're soaked," he growled, his voice thick with disbelief and lust. Two thick fingers plunged into her without warning, stretching her, filling her. A guttural moan tore from her throat. "So fuckin' ready. Always were a desperate little thing, weren't you?" His thumb found her swollen clit, rubbing rough, rapid circles that sent sparks shooting behind her eyes.

"Will! Please!" It wasn't a protest. It was a plea, raw and needy. She ground herself shamelessly against his hand, chasing the friction, the pressure, anything to relieve the desperate ache.

He withdrew his fingers, slick and glistening. Before she could whine at the loss, he grabbed her hips, lifting her effortlessly. Her back scraped against the unforgiving wood of the shelf as he spun her, pinning her against it. Her legs instinctively wrapped around his waist, ankles locking at the small of his back. He guided himself, the broad, slick head of his cock nudging against her drenched entrance. His green-gold eyes burned into hers, holding her gaze captive.

"No fairy tale bullshit, Candy," he muttered, his breath hot on her face. "This is it. Raw. Right fucking here."

Then he surged forward.

A sharp cry escaped her lips as he filled her, thick and deep, stretching her unbearably in one hard thrust. It burned, a delicious, tearing friction that stole her breath. He buried himself to the hilt inside her, grinding his pelvis against hers, forcing her clit against the rough denim still covering his lower hips. The sensation was brutal, overwhelming – pain and pleasure colliding in a dizzying wave. He held himself there, buried deep, his body trembling slightly with the effort of restraint, his cock pulsing hotly inside her.

"Christ," he choked out, his forehead pressed against hers. "Still tight as a goddamn fist."

She couldn't speak. Could only gasp, her fingers clawing at the muscles bunching under his shirt. She felt impaled, stretched impossibly wide, filled to bursting. The aching emptiness she’d carried for years was obliterated, replaced by this searing, consuming fullness. He pulled back slowly, dragging against her sensitized inner walls, drawing a ragged whimper from her throat. Then he slammed back in. Harder. Deeper.

There was no rhythm at first, just raw, desperate pistoning. Short, brutal strokes that drove her spine repeatedly against the shelf, rattling the books around them. Each thrust forced a gasp or a broken moan from her lips. The sounds were obscene in the library quiet – wet flesh slapping, their harsh breaths mingling, the creak of the old shelving unit protesting the assault.

He leaned in, his mouth capturing hers again in a fierce, biting kiss. His tongue invaded her mouth, mimicking the ruthless rhythm of his hips. She tasted blood – maybe hers, maybe his. She didn't care. Her hands flew to the back of his head, holding him there, demanding more, kissing him back with a ferocity that matched his own. She bit his lower lip, hard. He groaned, a sound halfway between pain and ecstasy, and drove into her harder, faster.

"Look at you," he rasped against her bruised lips, pulling back slightly. His gaze raked down her body – blouse gaping open, breasts bouncing wildly with each powerful thrust, skirt hiked obscenely high, legs wrapped desperately around him. "My quiet librarian... taking my cock like a goddamn whore against the bookshelves."

The crude words shouldn't have excited her. But they did. They ignited something feral, something buried deep beneath layers of propriety. She clenched around him, hard, milking his thick length, drawing a ragged curse from him. "Fuck! Yeah... just like that... squeeze me..." His hips snapped forward with renewed fury, the base of his cock grinding against her clit on every deep plunge.

The coiling tension inside her snapped abruptly. Pleasure detonated, shattering through her like broken glass. She came with a sharp, wordless cry, her body clamping down on him in violent spasms, her vision whiting out. She dug her nails into his shoulders, clinging to him as the relentless waves crashed through her.

He felt it, the frantic pulsing of her climax milking his cock. A savage groan ripped from his chest. He grabbed her ass with both hands, fingers digging bruisingly into the soft flesh, lifting her slightly higher and driving into her with even deeper, harder strokes. "Gonna fill you up," he growled, his voice guttural, almost feral. "Gonna pump you full..."

He slammed into her one final, punishing time, hilt deep, and held himself there. She felt the hot, liquid surge as he came inside her, thick jets pulsing against her deepest walls. His entire body shuddered violently against hers, his face buried in the crook of her neck, his teeth grazing her skin. The low, guttural sounds he made vibrated through her bones.

They stayed locked together, panting harshly in the sudden quiet, the only sounds their ragged breathing and the faint settling of disturbed books. His cock softened slowly inside her, still buried deep. The reality of where they were – the dusty shelves, the smell of sex thick in the air, her underwear tangled around one ankle – crashed over Candace. Shame warred fiercely with the lingering tremors of pleasure still vibrating through her core. She felt sticky, exposed, utterly undone.

He lifted his head, his eyes hooded, unreadable. He carefully lowered her legs, her knees threatening to buckle. She wobbled, grabbing the shelf for support as he pulled out. A rush of warm wetness trickled down her inner thigh. He tucked himself away, zipping his jeans with quick, economical movements, not looking at her. The silence stretched, thick and suffocating.

He picked up the historical saga she’d handed him earlier, its lurid cover gleaming under the dim light. He tapped the spine thoughtfully. "Guess I'll borrow this." His voice was flat, devoid of the rough heat from moments before. He turned towards the circulation desk, leaving her standing there, blouse gaping, skirt askew, the scent of their coupling clinging to her skin like a dirty secret. "Better check it out."

The silence after he spoke was thick with unspoken things – sweat, the sharp tang of sex, and the cloying scent of dust disturbed by their violence against the shelves. Candace leaned heavily against the unforgiving wood, the Botany of the Eastern Seaboard spine digging into her shoulder blade. Her blouse gaped open, revealing the flushed skin of her chest and the reddened swell of her breast above her now-lopsided bra. Her sensible floral skirt was rucked up around her waist, her cotton panties a tangled mess around one ankle. The warm, sticky trickle down her inner thigh felt obscene, a stark physical reminder of what just happened, where it just happened.

Will didn't look back. He just tapped the lurid romance novel cover and walked towards the circulation desk, his gait slightly stiff. The casual dismissal, the flatness in his voice – "Better check it out" – landed like a physical blow. It wasn't anger in her chest now; it was a hollow, aching terror. The fantasy man from her wildest, most secret daydreams had just used her like a cheap thrill against the historical fiction section and was walking away without a second glance. She felt exposed, foolish, and utterly disposable. The fear of becoming the town spinster wasn't a shadow anymore; it was a gaping maw threatening to swallow her whole, right there on the library floor.

Panic clawed its way up her throat, sharp and desperate. The years of loneliness, the quiet desperation masked by cardigans and book stamps, surged forward in a sickening wave. He couldn't just leave. Not like this. Not after that. The raw power he’d wielded over her body, the way he’d shattered her carefully constructed composure – it had been terrifying and electrifying. He’d seen her, truly seen the desperate, hungry creature beneath the librarian’s veneer, and instead of recoiling, he’d wanted it. Craved it. And now he was leaving.

Before conscious thought could intervene, before shame could reassert its suffocating grip, her body moved. Driven by a primal surge of fear and a terrifying, burgeoning need for more – more of his attention, more of that obliterating sensation, more validation that she wasn't just forgotten dust on a shelf – she pushed off from the bookcase.

Her knees hit the worn linoleum hard. The impact jarred up her thighs, but the sting was irrelevant. She shuffled forward on her knees, the rough floor scraping the skin, the bunched skirt dragging. She reached him just as he slid the book across the counter towards the empty space where she should have been standing.

Will turned, startled, his brow furrowing as he looked down. "Candy? What the fu—"

Her hands were already fumbling at the snap and zipper of his jeans. Her fingers, trembling but determined, found the warm denim, yanking it down his hips again, revealing the heavy, semi-hard length of him nestled in dark curls. The musky scent of their recent coupling intensified. He hadn't fully softened, the thick shaft starting to swell again almost immediately under her frantic attention.

"Fuck," he breathed, a low rumble of surprise that vibrated in the quiet library.

She didn't hesitate. Didn't look up. She leaned forward, her auburn curls falling around her face as her mouth opened. Her tongue darted out, a tentative, desperate lick along the underside of his cock, tasting salt and the potent, primal essence of him. He hissed, his hand instinctively tangling in her hair, not pulling, just holding.

Encouraged, driven by the sheer terror of being abandoned and the dizzying power she suddenly felt holding this rigid flesh in her hands, she took him deeper. Her lips stretched around the broad, spongy head, sucking gently, her tongue swirling. She felt him pulse, thickening rapidly in her mouth. The sensation was overwhelming – the heat, the velvet-over-steel texture, the sheer size of him forcing her jaw wide. Saliva pooled, trickling down her chin as she worked, her movements clumsy with inexperience but frantic with need.

"Jesus, Candy," Will groaned, his fingers tightening in her hair, guiding her head slightly. "Where'd this come from, huh? My shy little librarian on her knees sucking cock?" His voice was thick again, the earlier flatness replaced by a dark, aroused curiosity. He pushed forward gently, testing. "Take it deeper. Show me how desperate you really are."

She gagged slightly as he nudged the back of her throat, tears springing to her eyes. But the humiliation, the burning in her throat, was secondary to the desperate compulsion driving her. She wanted that look back in his eyes. The one that saw her, the hungry one. She forced herself to relax her throat, taking another inch, her nose pressing into the wiry hair at his base. Her hand wrapped around the thick base he couldn’t reach, pumping slowly in time with the shallow bobbing of her head. She hollowed her cheeks, sucking hard, the filthy, wet sounds loud in the hushed library – the slick slide of her lips, her muffled gasps for breath, his harsh groans.

"Yeah, fuck, just like that," he rasped, his hips giving an involuntary little thrust. "Use that pretty mouth. Show me you ain't just shelf dust." His thumb stroked her temple, a gesture that felt shockingly intimate juxtaposed with the crude command and the act itself. "Good girl. Taking it so deep for me. So fucking eager."

His words, demeaning and thrilling, sent a fresh jolt of heat straight to her core. She moaned around him, the vibration making him curse and thrust harder. She felt utterly debased, on her knees in her ruined work clothes, servicing him like some backroom whore. Yet, paradoxically, a fierce sense of agency surged through her. She had made him groan. She had summoned that rough, approving tone. She had stopped him from walking away. It was messy, it was wrong, it was everything she’d been terrified of becoming… and in this moment, kneeling on the library floor with his cock stretching her mouth, Candace Armitage felt more powerfully alive, more seen, than she had in a decade.

She sucked harder, faster, driven by a frantic mix of terror, obsession, and the raw, undeniable thrill of having this powerful, dangerous man trembling above her. Her jaw ached, her throat burned, but she didn't stop. She couldn't. His grip tightened in her hair, pulling her head back slightly to look down at her. Her eyes, wide and watery, met his. They were dark, intense, utterly focused on her mouth stretched obscenely around him. The sight seemed to push him over the edge.

"Gonna come," he choked out, a warning and a command. "Swallow it all, Candy. Every fucking drop."

His cock pulsed violently on her tongue. A hot, salty bitterness flooded her mouth, thick and copious. She gagged, tears streaming down her cheeks now, but forced herself to swallow convulsively, again and again, the taste overwhelming, the act one of total, degrading submission. He held her head firmly in place, riding out the last pulses deep in her throat, his groan a long, low sound of release that echoed off the silent books.

Finally, he released her hair. She slumped back on her heels, panting, saliva and traces of him glistening on her lips and chin. She wiped her mouth with the back of her hand, the gesture automatic, her eyes wide and dazed, fixed on the damp, softening cock still exposed before her. The reality of it crashed down again – the floor hard under her knees, the dusty smell mixing with sex and salt, the complete abandonment of everything she pretended to be. He tucked himself away, zipped up, his movements deliberate. He looked down at her, kneeling amidst scattered books and her own unraveled dignity, a complex expression flickering in his eyes – satisfaction, lingering heat, and something darker, more calculating.

He picked the romance novel back up from the counter. "Good girl," he said again, his voice rough but quieter now. He tapped the book cover once more. "Definitely checking this out." He turned towards the door, stepping over a fallen paperback without a glance.

The bell above the library door jingled cheerfully as he left. Candace remained on her knees, the taste of him lingering in her mouth, the echo of his command – "Swallow it all" – ringing in her ears. Outside, the sleepy sounds of Willow Creek continued. Inside, the silence of the library pressed in, heavy with the weight of what she’d just done, and the terrifying, obsessive seed taking root deep inside her. The spinster was gone. Something else, something raw and hungry and dangerous, had taken her place.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI