Cover of Both of Us Lied

Romance

Both of Us Lied

Read the story

4 chapters · 6713 words · Read 0 times

A his and hers thriller set in the north Georgia mountains. Atlanta news anchor Nadia Kerr has just lost the evening slot, and the station sends her back to Hollis Gap, the hometown she swore she'd never see again, to cover a body found in the woods. The victim is her oldest friend. The lead detective is Rhys Hale, the husband she walked out on. Both of them swear they hadn't seen Caro Dunning in a year. Both of them are lying, and the photos arriving on their phones prove it. Dual POV, second chance romance, estranged spouses and a killer who knows every secret of their marriage. Which side of the story is true, and who is watching them tell it?

Characters

  • Caroline "Caro" Dunning — Nadia's oldest friend and the source behind the story that made her name. She is found dead below the old fire tower with a motel key tag in her hand.
  • Duke Alvarez — Nadia's long-suffering cameraman, who notices everything in the frame.
  • Jolene Price — Rhys's partner, new to Hollis Gap and the only person in town who isn't impressed by either of them.
  • Lyle Cobb — Rhys's former partner, whose career ended the night Nadia named him on air.
  • Nadia Kerr — An Atlanta news anchor who built her career on one explosive story from her hometown. Bumped from the evening slot, she is sent home to cover a death she has her own reasons to fear.
  • Rhys Hale — The Tolliver County detective leading the investigation, and Nadia's estranged husband. Everyone in Hollis Gap thinks he's the most honest man in town. He's lying too.

Chapter 2: His: Room Six

Rhys Hale had seen a lot of dead people in nineteen years with the county, and most of them had looked surprised.

Caro Dunning didn't. That was the first thing he'd noticed, standing over her at seven that morning with the dew still on the leaves and the hiker throwing up politely behind a hemlock. She lay on her back in the ferns at the foot of the fire tower with one arm flung out and her copper curls fanned around her head, and her face was calm, almost amused, as if she'd lain down to look at the stars and found them funnier than expected.

The second thing he noticed was her right hand. It was closed. Not clenched, just closed, the way you'd hold a coin you meant to give somebody.

"You want to do it, or should I?" Jolene Price had asked, crouching on the other side with her gloves on.

"Go ahead."

Jolene had worked her fingers open, gently, and there in Caro's palm was a key tag. The old-fashioned kind, a diamond of brass gone green at the edges, with a hole for a ring and a number stamped deep in the middle. Pine Hollow Motor Court. Room 6.

"Pine Hollow," Jolene said. "That's the dump out on Route 9 with the busted sign? Shut down years ago?"

"Eight years," Rhys said.

He'd kept his voice level. He was good at that. He'd watched Jolene drop the tag into an evidence bag and seal it and write the time across the seal in her neat, slanted capitals, and he'd said nothing at all about the last time he'd seen a key tag like that. It had been on a motel desk under a lamp with a burn hole in the shade, the night he married Nadia Kerr. They'd had sixty-one dollars between them after the reception, and a borrowed truck, and the honeymoon suite at Pine Hollow was the only room within forty miles that came with a vending machine and a view of the creek. She'd laughed so hard at the wallpaper she'd had to sit down on the floor.

Room 6. Nobody alive knew about Room 6 but him and his wife.

And now, apparently, whoever had put it in Caro's hand.

"Thanks for coming in," Rhys said.

"Did I have a choice?"

"You always have a choice. You're just usually wrong about which one to make."

Nadia's mouth twitched. She caught it before it became anything. She sat across from him in Interview Two, which was also the break room on Tuesdays and still smelled faintly of somebody's microwaved fish, wearing a camel coat she hadn't taken off and an expression of such polished, attentive calm that he wanted to reach across the table and rumple it.

Four years. She looked good. She looked like television. Her hair was a sharp black line at her jaw instead of the long braid she used to wear down her back, and her posture was so straight she could have balanced a coffee cup on her head. But her eyes were the same. Dark and quick and taking an inventory of everything: the room, the camera in the corner, the coffee ring on the table, him.

Jolene sat at the end of the table with a legal pad and said nothing, which was Jolene's way of saying a great deal.

"When did you get into town?" Rhys asked.

"Yesterday afternoon. About three thirty."

"And before that? When were you last in Hollis Gap?"

"Four years ago." A small, cool smile. "You were there. You might remember. You drove me to the bus."

He remembered. He remembered her suitcase with the broken wheel. He remembered her not looking back.

"When did you last speak to Caroline Dunning?"

"About a year ago. She called on my birthday."

"Not since?"

"Not since."

On the table, Nadia's right hand rested over her left, the very picture of composure. And under her right index finger, almost hidden, the silver ring on her thumb was turning. Slowly. Once around. Twice.

Rhys had given her that ring at a gas station outside Chattanooga when they were twenty-four, because she'd lost her real one swimming in the creek and cried about it and then pretended she hadn't. It had cost four dollars. She had told him, two years later, that she turned it whenever she was lying, because the guilt had to go somewhere and her thumb was handy. She'd made him swear never to tell anyone. She'd been laughing when she said it.

He didn't think she remembered telling him.

"Okay," he said. "Thank you. That's all for now."

Jolene's head turned toward him, sharp as a bird's.

"That's it?" Nadia said. A flicker of something, surprise or suspicion, quickly smoothed over.

"Unless you've got something else to tell me."

The pause lasted one second too long.

"No," said his wife. "Nothing."

"She's lying," Jolene said, the moment the door shut behind Nadia's camel coat.

"She's a journalist." Rhys capped his pen. "Lying's in the job description. Right after 'good hair'."

"Funny. She's lying about the victim, and you let her walk." Jolene took off her glasses and cleaned them on her windbreaker, which was something she did when she was deciding how rude to be. She'd been his partner for eight months. She was the sharpest detective he'd worked with since Lyle Cobb, which was a compliment he'd never say out loud, given how things had gone with Lyle. "You want to tell me why?"

"Because if she's lying, she'll do it again, and next time she'll do it somewhere I can prove it."

"Uh-huh." Jolene put the glasses back on. "And you? You told me this morning you hadn't seen Caro Dunning in a year either."

"That's right."

"Everybody in this town says Caro was in and out of every house on Main Street. Knew everybody's business. Came to the department picnic in July and beat you at horseshoes. Folks remember that." Jolene's eyes were very steady behind the gold rims. "But you hadn't seen her in a year."

"Not to talk to."

"Okay." She stood, and tucked the legal pad under her arm. At the door, she paused. "I'm going to go pull her phone records, Rhys. Just so you know. All of them."

"Good," he said. "That's what I'd do."

The door closed. Rhys sat alone in the room that smelled of fish and looked at the scar on the back of his right hand, the pale shiny map of it, and thought about how easily he'd said it. Not to talk to.

What he hadn't told Jolene was this.

Two nights ago, at about a quarter after nine, Caroline Dunning had knocked on his kitchen door in the rain. Not the front. The kitchen, at the side of the house, the door only people who'd known him for twenty years ever used. She'd been soaked. She'd been shaking. She'd stood dripping on the mat and asked for a beer, and he'd given her one, and she hadn't drunk it. She'd just turned it round and round in her hands with her mismatched rings clinking against the glass.

"The Cobb thing," she'd said. "The evidence. Lyle didn't do it, Rhys. Somebody set him up, and they did it from inside your office, and they used me to get it out."

He'd sat down very slowly.

Five years ago, Nadia had gone on air in Atlanta with a story that took the Tolliver County Sheriff's Office apart at the joints. Evidence logs altered. Seized cash gone missing from the property room. A deputy named Lyle Cobb, twenty-two years on the force, Rhys's partner and the man who'd taught him how to read a scene, caught on paper doing all of it. Lyle had lost his badge and his pension and his wife. The sheriff had retired. The state had come in and turned the place upside down. And Nadia had won an award and a job offer in the same month, and had taken both.

It had been the beginning of the end of them. He'd known it at the time. She'd never told him who her source was, and he'd never forgiven her for not telling him, and she'd never forgiven him for asking.

"It was you," he'd said to Caro, at his kitchen table. "You gave her the papers."

"Somebody gave them to me first. Said they were real. I believed it." Caro's eyes had filled. "I've been finding out for a year that they weren't. I've got proof now. Most of it. I need to show Nadia first, Rhys. I owe her that. I put her name on a lie. She has to hear it from me before anybody."

"Tell me who."

"Tomorrow," she'd said. "After I've seen her. I promise."

He had let her go. He had stood in his kitchen doorway and watched her tail-lights go down the hill in the rain, not long before midnight, and he had thought, I'll call her in the morning. He'd thought it so clearly he could still hear it.

In the morning she'd been lying in the ferns with Room 6 in her hand.

He hadn't told Jolene, because the minute he did, he would have to say Nadia's name. And he wasn't ready to find out what she'd done with that night.

He got home a little after nine. The house was dark and too big, the way it had been for four years. He sat on the porch step with a beer he didn't open, a habit he'd apparently caught from the dead, and listened to the creek.

His phone buzzed.

Unknown number. A photograph. He opened it and sat very still.

It was taken at night, with a flash, from a distance. The gravel lot at the foot of the fire tower. A silver sedan parked alone under the single sodium light, Atlanta plates, a parking permit for a downtown garage stuck to the windshield. He knew that car. He'd helped her pick it out. Through the windshield, lit blue by a phone screen, a woman's face. Dark hair at the jaw.

The timestamp in the corner said four minutes past midnight, two nights ago.

Underneath, a message:

Ask your wife where she was.

He was still staring at it when the phone buzzed again.

A second photograph. Same flash, same night. His own house, from the road. The kitchen window lit. A small red car in the drive that had belonged to Caro Dunning for as long as he could remember.

Or should I ask you?

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI