Cover of Both of Us Lied

Romance

Both of Us Lied

Read the story

4 chapters · 6713 words · Read 0 times

A his and hers thriller set in the north Georgia mountains. Atlanta news anchor Nadia Kerr has just lost the evening slot, and the station sends her back to Hollis Gap, the hometown she swore she'd never see again, to cover a body found in the woods. The victim is her oldest friend. The lead detective is Rhys Hale, the husband she walked out on. Both of them swear they hadn't seen Caro Dunning in a year. Both of them are lying, and the photos arriving on their phones prove it. Dual POV, second chance romance, estranged spouses and a killer who knows every secret of their marriage. Which side of the story is true, and who is watching them tell it?

Characters

  • Caroline "Caro" Dunning — Nadia's oldest friend and the source behind the story that made her name. She is found dead below the old fire tower with a motel key tag in her hand.
  • Duke Alvarez — Nadia's long-suffering cameraman, who notices everything in the frame.
  • Jolene Price — Rhys's partner, new to Hollis Gap and the only person in town who isn't impressed by either of them.
  • Lyle Cobb — Rhys's former partner, whose career ended the night Nadia named him on air.
  • Nadia Kerr — An Atlanta news anchor who built her career on one explosive story from her hometown. Bumped from the evening slot, she is sent home to cover a death she has her own reasons to fear.
  • Rhys Hale — The Tolliver County detective leading the investigation, and Nadia's estranged husband. Everyone in Hollis Gap thinks he's the most honest man in town. He's lying too.

Chapter 4: His: The Honeymoon Suite

He gave her a towel and the yellow mug.

He didn't mean to give her the yellow mug. His hands just went to it, at the back of the cupboard behind the good glasses, where it had been for four years because he couldn't use it and couldn't throw it out. It had a cartoon sun on it, grinning, and a crack down the handle she'd glued herself. He made the coffee the way she liked it, which was wrong, two sugars and far too much milk, a drink he'd once described as warm pudding. He set it in front of her at the kitchen table without a word.

Nadia looked down at the mug. Then up at him. Her hair was plastered flat and black against her cheeks and she had the towel round her shoulders like a boxer between rounds.

"You kept it," she said.

"It's a mug, Nadia."

"You kept it at the back. Behind the good glasses. So you wouldn't have to look at it." She wrapped both hands around it. "I know where you hide things, Rhys. I lived here."

He sat down across from her. The kitchen was the colour she'd painted it, Morning Butter, a shade he had complained about loudly for nine years and had not been able to make himself paint over for four. Rain drummed on the tin roof like a crowd that wanted something.

"You first," he said.

"Why me?"

"Because you lied to me in an interview room, with a camera running, and twisted that ring so hard I thought your thumb was going to come off."

She went still. Then she looked down at her right hand, at the cheap silver ring, and something happened to her face that he hadn't seen in four years. It cracked. Just slightly, at the edges, like ice on the creek in March.

"You remembered," she said.

"I remember everything you ever told me." He hadn't meant to say that either. "Go on."

So she told him. Caro's texts, out of nowhere, on the burner she'd kept for five years. The drive up in the dark, two hours, telling Marcy she had a migraine. The gravel lot at the foot of the tower, the single orange light, her own breath fogging the windshield. Midnight. "I waited," she said. "Half an hour. An hour. Nearly two. I sent her four messages. Then I drove back to Atlanta and was at my desk by nine with concealer on, and I didn't tell anybody. Not even when they found her. Especially not then."

"Why?"

"Because the first question anybody asks is why was Caro Dunning texting you at midnight. And the answer is that she was my source. And the next answer is that she called me to tell me the story I built my whole career on was a lie." Her voice was very steady and her eyes were not. "I wasn't protecting my job, Rhys. Or not only that. I was protecting the one thing I had to show for leaving. If it was a lie, then I left you for nothing."

The rain went on.

"Your turn," she said.

So he told her. The knock at the kitchen door. The beer Caro didn't drink. A badge, she'd said, someone inside the office, and Tomorrow, after I've seen Nadia, I promise. Her tail-lights going down the hill in the rain. The phone call he'd been going to make in the morning.

"Her car turned up this afternoon," he said. "Jolene found it. Behind Pine Hollow, round the back where the old ice machine is. Keys still in it."

Nadia stared at him. "Pine Hollow. Not the tower."

"Not the tower. She left here heading for you, and somewhere in between, she turned off for a dead motel instead." He rubbed the scar on the back of his hand. "Somebody told her to meet there. Somebody she'd go to, alone, at night, without calling either of us."

"And then they moved her," Nadia said slowly, "to the tower. Two hundred yards from where I was sitting in my car."

"With Room 6 in her hand."

They looked at each other across the table, and for the first time in four years, it wasn't across anything.

"You told me you hadn't seen her in a year," Nadia said. "In front of the whole town. On the courthouse steps."

"You told me you hadn't been home in four."

"I was trying to protect myself."

"I was trying to protect you." He heard his own voice come out rough. "The second I told Jolene Caro left my house heading for a midnight meeting, the next question is who with. And I knew. I didn't know how, but I knew it was you. I've always known when you were close. It's like weather. I could feel you in town before I saw you at the tape."

She put the mug down very carefully, as if it might break.

"You never asked me who my source was," she said. "Not once, after the first time. You just stopped talking to me."

"You never told me. I thought that meant you didn't trust me."

"It meant I knew you'd ask me to drop it. And I'd have done it. For you. I'd have dropped it and stayed here and hated you for the rest of my life." Her eyes were wet. "So I left instead, and hated myself. It seemed fairer."

"It wasn't."

"No," she said. "It really wasn't."

He didn't decide to stand up. He was just standing, and so was she, and the table that had been between them wasn't anymore. Her hand came up and found the leather cord at his collar and followed it down to the ring, and held it, warm from being worn, between her finger and thumb.

"You still wear it," she said.

"I never had a reason to stop."

He took her hand, and she held on. Later, neither of them would be able to say who reached first, and they'd argue about it, happily, for years. It was a moment that tasted of rain and terrible sweet coffee and four years of not saying anything, and her fingers were tight around his, and somewhere under the drumming of the roof he heard her laugh, once, as if she couldn't quite believe it either.

When they finally stepped apart, she kept hold of the cord.

"I'm still mad at you," she said.

"I know."

"I'm going to be mad at you for a long time."

"I'll wait," he said. "I'm good at it. Ask your mama's lawn."

The sign at Pine Hollow Motor Court had been dark for eight years, a tall rusted arrow with the bulbs knocked out. The rain had eased to a mist. Their headlights swept across a row of doors in peeling turquoise, each with a brass number, and a drained pool half full of leaves.

Number 6 was ajar.

Rhys drew his weapon and went in first, and Nadia, who had never in her life stayed in a car when she was told to, came in right behind him with her phone torch up.

The room smelled of damp carpet and something sharper. Fresh. Ink, or chemicals. The sagging furniture was gone. The lamp with the burn in the shade was gone. Every wall, floor to ceiling, was covered in photographs.

Him and Nadia on the courthouse steps on their wedding day, her braid over her shoulder, both of them squinting into the sun. Nadia at the bus station four years ago with her broken suitcase, not looking back. Rhys mowing Pearl's lawn in a sweat-dark shirt. Nadia on a balcony in Atlanta in a bathrobe, drinking coffee, taken from very far away. Rhys at the range. Nadia leaving the station after the six o'clock. Hundreds of them. Years of them. A long, patient life, lived alongside theirs, without either of them ever once feeling it.

"Rhys," Nadia whispered.

She was pointing at the mirror over the dresser. Tucked into the frame, so fresh the print was still curling at the corners, was a photograph of a lit kitchen window the colour of butter, and two people in it, holding each other. Taken from the road, less than an hour ago.

"Who knew about this room?" she said. "Who, Rhys? Think."

He was thinking. He'd been thinking since that morning in the ferns. "Us. And whoever paid for it."

"Paid for it? We paid for it."

"We didn't." It came up out of a part of his memory he hadn't visited in years. "There was an envelope at the desk when we checked in. The room was covered. Card said congratulations, from a friend. You were laughing so hard at the wallpaper I never told you. I figured it was your mama."

"Mama doesn't know this place exists."

In both their pockets, at exactly the same moment, their phones buzzed.

Nadia read hers aloud. Her voice was very calm, in the way it only got when things were very bad.

"Room 7's made up and waiting. Next time one of you lies, the other one gets the key."

And outside, across the wet lot, somewhere past the drained pool, an engine they hadn't heard arrive turned over, and a car with no lights on rolled away into the dark.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI