Cover of Both of Us Lied

Romance

Both of Us Lied

Read the story

4 chapters · 6713 words · Read 0 times

A his and hers thriller set in the north Georgia mountains. Atlanta news anchor Nadia Kerr has just lost the evening slot, and the station sends her back to Hollis Gap, the hometown she swore she'd never see again, to cover a body found in the woods. The victim is her oldest friend. The lead detective is Rhys Hale, the husband she walked out on. Both of them swear they hadn't seen Caro Dunning in a year. Both of them are lying, and the photos arriving on their phones prove it. Dual POV, second chance romance, estranged spouses and a killer who knows every secret of their marriage. Which side of the story is true, and who is watching them tell it?

Characters

  • Caroline "Caro" Dunning — Nadia's oldest friend and the source behind the story that made her name. She is found dead below the old fire tower with a motel key tag in her hand.
  • Duke Alvarez — Nadia's long-suffering cameraman, who notices everything in the frame.
  • Jolene Price — Rhys's partner, new to Hollis Gap and the only person in town who isn't impressed by either of them.
  • Lyle Cobb — Rhys's former partner, whose career ended the night Nadia named him on air.
  • Nadia Kerr — An Atlanta news anchor who built her career on one explosive story from her hometown. Bumped from the evening slot, she is sent home to cover a death she has her own reasons to fear.
  • Rhys Hale — The Tolliver County detective leading the investigation, and Nadia's estranged husband. Everyone in Hollis Gap thinks he's the most honest man in town. He's lying too.

Chapter 3: Hers: Off the Record

Pearl Kerr believed there was no grief on earth that could not be at least partially addressed with biscuits, and she had been up since five testing the theory.

"Eat," she said.

"Mama, I'm not hungry."

"I didn't ask if you were hungry. I said eat." Pearl put a third biscuit on Nadia's plate and a jar of fig preserves beside it, and sat down across the kitchen table in her quilted housecoat with her reading glasses pushed up into her white hair. She was sixty-seven and had buried a husband and a sister and, as of yesterday, the friend who used to turn up every Friday night and eat all her pimento cheese. Her eyes were red-rimmed. Her chin was not.

"How'd the detective do you?" she asked.

"Fine. He asked questions. I answered them."

"Mm-hm." Pearl spread preserves with great attention. "He still mows my lawn, you know. Every other Saturday. Fixed the porch swing in April. Never once came in for a glass of tea, just does it and goes. I think he thinks if he stops, it means something."

Nadia looked down at her biscuit. "Mama."

"I'm only telling you."

"I know what you're doing."

"Then you don't need me to do it." Pearl reached over and squeezed her wrist, hard, the way she had before Nadia's first job interview and her first night on air. "Caro came by here, last week. Thursday, I think. Asked had I heard from you. I said you were too famous to call your mother. She laughed." Pearl's mouth wobbled, and firmed. "She looked tired, baby. Like she was carrying something up a hill."

The Tolliver County Sheriff's Office held its press briefing at noon on the courthouse steps, under a magnolia that dropped a leaf on Sheriff Dale Wofford's hat halfway through. Wofford was big and genial and pink in the face, a man built to shake hands at fish fries. He'd been a sergeant five years ago, before the state review emptied the top floor, and had come out of it with a promotion and a reputation for cleaning house.

"A tragedy," he said, more than once. "A beloved member of our community." The cause of death was under investigation. The public was not believed to be at risk. Detective Hale, standing two steps down with his hands in his jacket pockets, confirmed that he had not been in contact with the victim in recent months, and declined to take questions.

Nadia, at the back of the crowd with Duke, watched him say it.

He didn't look at her once. That was how she knew he'd seen her.

Cobb's Bait and Tackle sat on stilts at the end of a gravel spit on Lake Varner, and it smelled like crickets and two-stroke oil. The sign out front had a fish on it with a cartoon smile, and someone had added a moustache in marker.

Lyle Cobb was behind the counter, counting nightcrawlers into a styrofoam cup. He looked up when the screen door slapped. He looked down again.

"Well," he said. "Come to finish the job?"

"Hello, Lyle."

"Ms Kerr." He put a lid on the cup. He'd put on weight since she'd last seen him, through a car window, the day of his hearing. His white walrus moustache was the same. So was the way he looked at her, as if she were something he'd found in a tackle box that he couldn't identify but wouldn't touch. "If you're here for a comment, I'll give you the same one I gave your people five years ago, and you can bleep it."

"I'm not here for a comment. I'm here about Caro."

The cup stopped moving.

"Caro Dunning came to see you," Nadia said, gambling. "Didn't she?"

For a long moment, he just looked at her. Outside, a boat motor coughed, and somebody on the dock laughed.

"Four weeks ago," he said at last. "Sat right there on that cooler. Cried for a good long while before she could get a word out." He wiped his hands on his apron. "Said she was sorry. Said she was the one who gave you those papers. Said somebody handed them to her and swore they were real, and she believed it, because who wouldn't believe someone with a badge?"

"A badge." Nadia's mouth was dry. "Whose badge?"

"She wouldn't say. Said she was getting proof first. Said she'd tell you before anybody, because she owed you, and then she'd tell Rhys, because she owed him more." Lyle's lip curled under the moustache. "I figured that was about right. You got the award. He got the ashes."

"Did she say when?"

"Tuesday. Said she'd see Rhys Tuesday night."

Tuesday night. Two nights ago. The night Caro had texted Nadia from somewhere, Tower lot tonight, midnight, and then never come.

Detective Hale confirmed that he had not been in contact with the victim in recent months.

"You know the funny thing?" Lyle said. He had turned away, and was rearranging packets of hooks on a pegboard that didn't need it. "That boy still wears his ring. Twenty-two years I worked that office, I never saw a man so dumb about a woman. On duty, off duty, at the range. Ties it on a string round his neck when he's working a scene so it won't fall in anything. Four years you've been gone." He shook his head. "Fool."

Nadia stood very still on the warped boards with the crickets chirring in their tank.

"Lyle," she said. "I'm sorry. For all of it. I should have checked harder."

"Yeah," he said, without turning around. "You should have."

Duke had the van doors open in the bait shop lot and his laptop balanced on an equipment case, scrubbing through yesterday's footage with his reading glasses on the end of his nose.

"You need to see something," he said.

"I've seen enough today."

"Humour me." He turned the screen toward her. "This is the wide I got before your live hit. Establishing shot. Trees, tape, coroner's van, sad people. Pretty. Now watch the treeline, top left. Right where the trail goes up toward the tower."

She leaned in. Pines. Shadows. The smudge of late light through branches.

And then, between two trunks, very small, something moved. A figure, a dark shape in a hood. Standing still. Holding something up in front of its face at chest height, and the something caught the sun for one frame and flashed.

"A phone," Duke said. "Filming. Same as half the town. Except everybody else is at the tape, and this one's up on the slope, a hundred yards back, on the wrong side of it. Inside the scene. And it's not pointed at the van." He zoomed, and the image broke up into blocks. "It's pointed at you."

She watched it three more times. The figure never moved. On the fourth time, she noticed that it lowered the phone right at the moment Rhys walked up to the tape, and raised it again when he walked away.

"Nadia," Duke said quietly. "What's going on? And don't tell me nothing again. I've known you six years. I filmed you crying over a dead dog in a flood in Valdosta. You don't do nothing."

Her work phone buzzed in her pocket. Then, a heartbeat after, the cheap plastic one in her coat.

Both of them. At once.

She pulled out the burner first. Unknown number. A photograph, taken at night, from the road. A white farmhouse on a hill with a green tin roof, the kitchen window lit gold. She knew every board of that house. She had painted the kitchen herself, a colour called Morning Butter that Rhys said made him feel like he lived inside an omelette. In the drive, nose to the porch, sat a small red car with a dented fender.

Caro's car. Rhys's house. Timestamped a quarter after nine, Tuesday night.

Ask your husband where he was.

Her hands were cold. She opened the work phone.

The same unknown number. A second photograph. This one was of her own face, through her own windshield, lit blue by the burner screen, in the gravel lot at the foot of the fire tower.

He has this one too. Who do you think is lying?

The rain started as she turned onto Creek Road, fat drops at first and then a solid grey sheet that made the wipers labour. She didn't remember deciding to drive there. She just found herself taking the turns she knew, past the church with the leaning steeple, past the Hendersons' cattle guard, up the hill to the white house with the green roof and the kitchen she'd painted the colour of butter.

The porch light was on.

He was sitting on the top step in the rain-spatter, in his shirtsleeves, with a bottle of beer he hadn't opened beside him and his phone in his hand. He watched her car come up the drive. He didn't stand.

She got out and walked up the path through the downpour, and stopped at the bottom of the steps, and held up her phone with the photograph of Caro's red car glowing in his drive.

Rhys looked at it for a long moment. Then he turned his own phone around and held it up to her: a silver sedan alone under a sodium light, and her own blue-lit face behind the glass.

Neither of them said anything. The rain hammered on the tin roof.

And as he lowered the phone, his shirt collar shifted, and in the porch light she saw the thin leather cord around his neck, and the plain gold band hanging from it, catching the light like it had never once been taken off.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI