Cover of Snowbound on the Northern Star

Historical

Snowbound on the Northern Star

Read the story

3 chapters · 6181 words · Read 0 times

A locked room mystery aboard a luxury sleeper train in the winter of 1934. Retired Edinburgh inspector Hamish Calder only wants a quiet journey south to London. Then a blizzard buries the Northern Star in a cutting high on the Pennine moors, and in the morning the shipping magnate Sir Edgar Thorne is found dead in his compartment, the door bolted from the inside and the snow on the window ledge untouched. Every passenger has an alibi, every alibi checks out, and every one of them sounds a little too practised. A snowbound train, a closed circle of suspects and a golden-age whodunit with a retired detective who is not as retired as he thought. How did death get through a bolted door, and who wanted Calder aboard to watch?

Characters

  • Captain Owen Price — A merchant navy master who was sacked for refusing to take the Marguerite to sea. He makes no secret of hating Thorne.
  • Dr. Fiona Galbraith — A Glasgow general practitioner on her way to a medical conference, and the only doctor aboard. She becomes Calder's sharpest ally, and possibly his most dangerous suspect.
  • Hamish Calder — A widowed detective inspector, two years retired from the Edinburgh City Police, travelling to London on a first-class ticket he cannot quite account for. He has always believed that the truth, told carefully enough, makes the best lie of all.
  • Jack Mulcahy — A travelling typewriter salesman who knows everyone's business by the soup course.
  • Mrs. Adelaide Venn — A widow from Leith travelling with her paid companion, Miss Ruth Abernethy. She claims to have slept through the whole night.
  • Rupert Lyle — Thorne's private secretary, who sleeps in the compartment next door and keeps every key his master owns.
  • Sir Edgar Thorne — A Clydeside shipowner who grew rich on cut corners, and who was cleared by an inquiry after his steamer Marguerite went down with all hands in 1929. He boards the Northern Star convinced that someone means to kill him.
  • The Hon. Celia Drummond — A society beauty once engaged to Thorne, who broke it off without explanation the year the Marguerite sank.
  • Wilfred Hobb — The Northern Star's sleeping-car attendant, who swears no one passed along his corridor all night.

Chapter 3: The Passenger Nobody Counted

They talked in the vestibule between the carriages, because it was the only place on the train where nobody could listen at a door. It was bitterly cold. Frost had grown in feathers across the little windows, and the light that came through them was white and grey and did nobody's face any favours.

"Alasdair was the clever one," Fiona Galbraith said. "Engines from the time he could hold a spanner. He was thirty-one. He'd written to say the Marguerite's pumps were a disgrace and he'd be looking for another berth when they got to Bergen." She had her arms wrapped round herself. "They never got to Bergen."

"And the ticket?"

She took it out of her handbag without being asked: a cream card, typed. Calder knew before he read it what the e's would look like.

He will be aboard the Northern Star. So will the others. Do as your conscience bids.

"It came three weeks ago, with the ticket. No name. I told myself I'd not go. Then I told myself I'd go and only look at him." Her mouth twisted. "I wanted to see if a man like that could eat his dinner. He could. He sent back the soup."

"Why didn't you tell me last night?"

"Because you sat across a table from me and talked to me as if I were a colleague." She said it to the frosted window. "Do you know how long it's been since a man did that? I didn't want to watch your face change." She turned back to him. "And this morning there was a dead man and it was too late to say it without sounding like a confession."

Calder considered her for a long moment: the strong face, the level eyes, the watch turned to the inside of her wrist.

"I'll have to keep an eye on you," he said.

"You said that yesterday."

"I meant it less yesterday."

Something that was nearly a smile went across her face. "Then you'd better make sure I didn't do it, Hamish."

It was the first time anyone had used his Christian name in two years. He found he didn't mind.

He had them back in the dining car within the half hour, every passenger in first class, and Hobb and Ainsley and the valet standing by the door.

"I'll make this simple," Calder said. "Each of you received a ticket for this train by post, with a typed card and no name. I'd like to see the cards."

Nobody moved. Then Captain Price laughed, a short bark with no humour in it, and dug in his reefer jacket and slapped his card on the table.

After that it went quickly. Father Moran's, from a battered breviary. Madame Lisowska's, from a glove. Miss Abernethy's, which she had to fetch, and which she laid down with fingers that trembled. Mrs. Venn's, produced from inside the bell of her ear trumpet, to Calder's private delight.

"I keep all my correspondence there," she said. "Nobody ever looks."

The Honourable Celia Drummond put hers down last, and then put her hand flat on top of it.

"You'll want to know why Edgar put a question mark by my name," she said. "I'll tell you. I saw his insurance papers on the Marguerite a month before she sailed. She was insured for three times her worth. I wrote to the Board of Trade inquiry, unsigned, and nobody ever read my letter, and I gave him back his ring." She lifted her hand from the card. "He never knew it was me. I think he wondered."

Dr. Galbraith laid her own beside them without a word.

"Mr. Mulcahy," said Calder. "You've not put one down."

"Never got one." The salesman spread his hands. "I paid for my ticket like a Christian, more's the pity."

Seven cards on the white cloth. Calder laid them in a row. Every one said the same thing, word for word. On every one, the e sat a little high and a little heavy, as though that key had been struck by a harder finger than the rest.

"Then you're the one man here with no stake in it, Mr. Mulcahy," Calder said. "And you're the expert."

The salesman came and bent over the table, and for once he wasn't smiling.

"Portable," he said after a moment. "Cheap one. You can see by the spacing. And the slug on the e is bent, see, it's been dropped or knocked, so it strikes high." He straightened. "Not one of mine, Inspector, if that's what you're asking. My samples are all brand new. I'll type you a line on every one of them if you like, and you'll not find an e out of place."

He did, too, sitting at the end table with three machines out of his case, clattering away while everybody watched. The quick brown fox, again and again. Every e sat neat on its line.

Dr. Galbraith came back from the dead man's compartment carrying two brown bottles, one in each hand.

"Sir Edgar's dressing case," she said. "Mr. Gray let me look. There's a spare, still sealed, from the same chemist, bought the same day." She held them both up to the window. One was a clear, pale straw colour. The other, the open bottle from the shelf, was dark amber, like strong tea. "Same label. Same handwriting on the label. Not the same medicine. I put a drop of each in a glass of water and tasted the tip of my finger, which I wouldn't recommend. The open one would stop a horse."

The dining car had gone very quiet.

"Mr. Gray," said Calder. "You told me Sir Edgar took the bottle down himself. When did he take his drops?"

The valet's composure flickered for the first time.

"At one o'clock, sir. Or a little after. He never slept well. He'd wake in the small hours and take five drops in water from the carafe, and go back to sleep. Always the same. And he always laid his watch face down at night, sir. The luminous dial kept him awake."

"And the Bible?"

It was Lyle who answered, hoarsely. "It came to the office in Glasgow with the last letter. That verse was already marked. He told me to pack it. He said if they were going to quote scripture at him, he'd read it himself and see what all the fuss was about."

Calder stood up. He hadn't meant to; it was an old habit from the courtroom, standing when a thing came clear.

"Then there's no mystery about the door," he said. "Sir Edgar bolted himself in at a quarter to midnight, the way he did every night, because he was frightened. He read his marked verse. He laid his watch face down. Around one he woke, as he always did, and he reached up to the shelf and took his drops, and lay down again." He looked round the car at the row of watching faces. "Nobody came into that compartment because nobody needed to. He locked himself in with the thing that killed him. It was standing on his own shelf."

Dr. Galbraith let out a long breath.

"So it could have been done anywhere," she said slowly. "In Glasgow. In Edinburgh. Any time in the last week, by anyone who could get near that dressing case."

"Aye."

"Then why the train?" It was Madame Lisowska, the first words she'd spoken unasked. Her accent thickened with feeling. "Why bring us all here? Why give us tickets?"

"Because a man who dies alone in his bed in Glasgow is a sad case for the procurator fiscal," Calder said. "A man who dies on a snowbound train surrounded by every family he ever wronged is a mystery with a carriage full of answers. You were brought here to be the crowd, madam. Someone wanted so many good reasons in one carriage that nobody could see the one that mattered."

Nobody looked at anybody else. That, he thought, was telling in itself.

"That leaves the watch," he said, half to himself.

"He laid it face down," said Gray. "I told you, sir."

"You did. But he wound it every night, I'd imagine, a man like that. And it stopped at a quarter past one." Calder picked up the gold watch from the table where he'd laid it and turned it in his fingers. "A man's heart can stop on its own. A watch is generally helped."

He went back to his compartment afterwards to sit for a few minutes in the quiet and think, and to find the notebook he had left in his ulster. The coat hung on its hook behind the door, heavy and damp at the hem from the corridor.

The ticket wallet was in the same pocket.

He took it out without really meaning to. Cream card, a brass star on the cover. He'd carried it a week and read the note inside a dozen times, and never once looked at it the way he'd looked at the seven cards on the dining-car tablecloth.

He looked now.

For services rendered. An old friend.

The e in services sat a little high and a little heavy. So did the one in rendered. So did the one in friend.

Calder sat down on the edge of his berth.

He had counted them all. Every passenger on the list, every alibi in its pair. He'd stood in the dining car and laid out seven cards like a hand of patience, and he had not once thought to count the man doing the laying.

The Leith docks business, Thorne had said. Back in 'twenty-four. You never made it stick. A bonded warehouse on the Shore, burned to the ground the night before an audit, a Thorne Line warehouse, and a night watchman named Archie Doig who hadn't got out. Calder had worked that case for eight months. He had known, the way you sometimes know, whose hand had paid for the match. He had never been able to prove it. In the end the Chief Constable had called him in and told him, very kindly, to let it go.

He had let it go. He'd thought nobody else remembered.

Somebody had. Somebody had looked at all the people Edgar Thorne had harmed, and written down the name of the policeman who had failed to stop him, and posted him a first-class ticket with a note that said thank you.

There was a knock, and Fiona Galbraith put her head round the door. She saw his face, and then the card in his hand, and came in and shut the door behind her and took it from him without asking. He watched her read it. He watched her see the e.

"Hamish," she said quietly. "You're on the list."

"I'm not on Thorne's list," he said. "I'm on theirs."

She sat down beside him on the berth, not touching, a careful hand's width of grey blanket between them, and for a while neither of them said anything at all. Out beyond the frosted glass the moor lay white to every horizon. The snowplough was a day away. Nobody was getting off this train.

Then, from the corridor outside, low and unhurried, a man began to hum.

Eternal Father, strong to save.

Two bars. Three. And then, exactly as before, in the middle of the line, it stopped.

Calder was on his feet with his hand on the door before the silence had finished falling. Beside him, Fiona Galbraith had gone quite still. She turned her wrist and looked at the watch on the inside of it, and he saw her lips move as she read the time.

"A quarter past one," she whispered. "To the minute. Whoever that is, Hamish, they're keeping time."

Read on DreamPress

Write your own story with AI