Cover of The Hidden Tape's Betrayal

The Hidden Tape's Betrayal

Read the story

3 chapters · 7860 words · Read 1 times

Sarah is in her older stepsisters bedroom and finds a video of her performing fellatio on her boyfriend. Monica, her stepsister comes in and catches Sarah.

Chapter 1: The Laptop's Secret

The closet smelled of lavender and old wool. Sarah pushed past a row of moth-eaten coats, their sleeves brushing her face like ghostly fingers. She’d only meant to borrow a sweater. Monica had said help yourself, and Sarah, house-sitting while her stepsister was supposedly away for the weekend, had taken it as a blanket invitation to explore.

The single bare bulb flickered when she pulled the chain, casting long, swaying shadows. It was less a closet and more a forgotten room, lined with half-empty perfume bottles on a dusty shelf and shoes piled in disordered heaps. At the back, wedged between a suitcase and a box of old textbooks, sat Monica’s sleek laptop.

Sarah bit her lip. Borrowing clothes was one thing. This was another.

Her hand hovered over the lid. Monica was everything Sarah wasn’t—confident, striking, with a life that seemed rehearsed for a movie. Sarah’s own existence felt like a rough draft. She opened the laptop. It woke instantly, no password. That was so like Monica, arrogant about her privacy because no one would dare.

The desktop was tidy. A folder caught her eye, innocuously labeled ‘Tax Docs 2023.’ Sarah almost clicked away, but a flutter of impulsive curiosity made her double-click instead.

Inside weren’t spreadsheets. There was a single video file, named ‘Private.’

She clicked it.

The video was dim, clearly shot on a phone propped up on a nightstand. The quality was intimate, shaky. And there was Monica. Her platinum hair was a mess against dark sheets, her face angled toward the camera with a look of focused concentration that was entirely foreign. Then the frame adjusted, and Sarah saw him—Derek, Monica’s boyfriend, his head thrown back.

Sarah’s breath stopped. Her stomach did a violent, swooping flip. Shock first, cold and piercing. Then something else, a low, unwelcome heat that spread from her core out to her fingertips, which had gone numb on the trackpad.

She should have closed it. She meant to. But she didn’t. She watched, mesmerized, by the raw, unvarnished skill of it, by Monica’s utter command of the moment. It was crude and beautiful and it made Sarah’s own few, fumbling experiences seem like childish pantomime. A strange cocktail of envy and arousal tightened her throat. Her face was hot. The closet air felt thick, dusty, too heavy to breathe.

The shadow fell over the screen so gradually she didn’t notice at first. The light just seemed to drain from the glowing rectangle, replaced by a tall, familiar silhouette.

Sarah froze. The heat in her face turned to ice.

“Enjoying the show, little sister?”

Monica’s voice was a low, calm growl. It held no surprise. Only a dark, simmering amusement.

Sarah jerked back from the laptop as if it had burned her, scrambling to her feet. Her hip slammed into the suitcase. “Monica! You’re… you said you were gone until Sunday.”

“Plans changed.” Monica leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed. She was dressed in a sleek black jumpsuit, her green eyes sharp as broken glass in the weak light. She looked from Sarah’s horrified face to the paused video on the screen, where her own image was forever frozen in an act of intimate expertise. “I see you made yourself at home.”

“I… I was just looking for a sweater,” Sarah stammered, the excuse pathetic even to her own ears.

“Right. And you just happened to find my laptop, open a hidden folder, and press play.” Monica pushed off the doorframe and took a slow step into the closet. The space shrank around them. “That’s a fascinating version of ‘looking for a sweater.’“

“I’m sorry,” Sarah blurted, tears of shame pricking her eyes. “I’m so sorry. It was an accident. I’ll go. I’ll just go.”

She tried to edge past, but Monica’s hand shot out, not touching her, just blocking the path. Her perfume, something expensive and citrus-sharp, cut through the scent of dust.

“Why are you crying?” Monica asked, her head tilting. “You weren’t crying a minute ago. You were biting your lip, leaning in. Looked pretty interested to me.”

“I wasn’t! I was shocked, I—”

“You were turned on.” Monica stated it plainly, a clinical observation.

Monica stated it plainly, a clinical observation. The words hung in the dusty air, stripping Sarah bare. She couldn’t even deny it; her body still hummed with a traitorous, shameful current.

“It’s okay,” Monica said, her voice dropping into something softer, yet no less dangerous. She took another step, and Sarah retreated until the cool wall of the closet pressed against her back. “Seriously. It’s okay. Curiosity isn’t a crime. Being turned on definitely isn’t.”

“I’m not—” Sarah began, but the protest died as Monica reached out and brushed a thumb over Sarah’s cheek, wiping away a tear she hadn’t even felt fall.

“You are. And it’s written all over your face. That’s the real crime here, you hiding from it.” Monica’s gaze was intense, capturing Sarah’s. “You watched because you wanted to know what it looks like. How it’s done. Right?”

Sarah’s mouth was dry. She nodded, a tiny, almost imperceptible movement.

A slow smile spread across Monica’s face. It wasn’t kind.It was predatory. “See?Honesty. So, let’s be honest about something else. You were jealous.”

“No, I wasn’t,” Sarah whispered.“Bullshit. You saw me doing something you don’t know how to do, and it pissed you off. It made you wet, and it pissed you off. That’s jealousy, baby.” Monica’s hand dropped from Sarah’s face to her shoulder, then slid down her arm, the touch electrifying through the thin cotton of Sarah’s t-shirt. “You want to know what it feels like? To have that kind of control?”

Sarah’s heart was a frantic drum against her ribs. “I don’t…”

“You do.” Monica’s hand closed around Sarah’s wrist, her grip firm. “It’s okay to want it. It’s okay to be a little dirty.Everyone is. Especially in here.” She gave a slight tug, pulling Sarah away from the wall, back toward the center of the cramped space. The laptop screen, still frozen on that explicit image, glowed beside them like a perverse altar.

Monica guided Sarah’s hand, not toward her own body, but back toward the laptop. She placed Sarah’s trembling fingers on the trackpad. “Go on. Rewind it. Watch that part again. The part where his whole body goes rigid.”

“Monica, stop,” Sarah gasped, but her fingers didn’t pull away. She felt paralyzed, hypnotized.“Why? You wanted to see. So see.” Monica’s other hand came up and cupped the back of Sarah’s neck, her fingers tangling in the mousy brown hair. Her lips were close to Sarah’s ear. “Watch what my mouth does. See how I use my tongue right there, under the head. That’s the spot.”

Sarah’s finger slid on the trackpad. The video jumped back thirty seconds. She hit play.

The sound, which she’d muted in her initial panic, now flooded the closet—low, guttural moans, the wet, rhythmic sounds she’d only imagined. Her knees felt weak. The heat between her legs was a throbbing, undeniable ache now.

“That’s it,” Monica murmured, her breath hot on Sarah’s skin. Her hand left Sarah’s wrist and trailed down Sarah’s side, coming to rest on the curve of her hip. “You feel it, don’t you? That empty, aching feeling. It’s annoying, isn’t it? Like an itch you can’t reach.”

Sarah was crying again, silent tears of confusion and desperate arousal. She nodded.

“It’s okay,” Monica repeated, her voice a dark velvet promise. “I can show you how to scratch it. But you have to stop lying. To me. To yourself.” Her hand slipped around to the front of Sarah’s jeans, palm pressing flat against the denim, right over the heart of that ache. Sarah jerked, a shockwave of pleasure-pain rocketing through her.

“Tell me what you want, Sarah.” Monica’s fingers found the button of her jeans, flicked it open. The zipper sound was obscenely loud. “Or I walk out, and you’re left here with just that video and your own clumsy fingers. Which is it?”

The choice was no choice at all. Trapped between the vivid, degrading images on the screen and the terrifying, magnetic reality of her stepsister’s touch, Sarah broke.

“You,” she choked out, the word ragged. “Show me.”

“Show me.”

The words hung in the dust motes, a surrender. Monica’s predatory smile widened. She didn’t move her hand from Sarah’s open jeans, just let her palm rest there, a hot, undeniable weight.

“Good girl,” Monica purred. Her fingers traced the edge of Sarah’s underwear, a feather-light touch that made Sarah gasp and arch off the wall. “See? Honesty feels better already.”

But then Monica withdrew her hand completely, leaving Sarah feeling exposed and strangely cold. She stepped back, smoothing her jumpsuit, a maestro deciding the next movement. Her eyes, gleaming in the bulb’s harsh light, scanned Sarah’s disheveled state—the flushed face, the open jeans, the trembling lower lip.

“You want a lesson,” Monica stated, her tone shifting to something cooler, more calculating. “A real one. Not just whispers in a closet.” She reached over and snapped the laptop lid shut, plunging the corner of the closet into deeper shadow. The sudden absence of that glowing screen felt like a loss.

Sarah stared, confused, her body still throbbing. “What… what do you mean?”

Monica leaned back against the opposite rack of coats, crossing her ankles. She looked utterly composed, a stark contrast to Sarah’s unraveling. “Watching a video is one thing. It’s passive. It’s theory.” She picked at a nonexistent piece of lint on her sleeve. “Application is everything. Context. The sounds, the smells, the… reactions.”

A slow, terrible understanding began to dawn on Sarah. Her stomach coiled.

“Derek’s on his way over,” Monica continued casually, as if discussing groceries. “He thinks I’m alone. He’s expecting… a welcome.” She let the implication hang, her green eyes pinned on Sarah, watching for the flinch. “He’ll be here in twenty minutes.”

Sarah’s mouth went dry. “You should… I should go.”

“You should stay,” Monica corrected, her voice flat. “You wanted to see how it’s done. This is your chance. Front row seat. No pixelated screen, no shaky camera.” She pushed off the coats and closed the small distance between them again. She didn’t touch Sarah this time, just loomed, her perfume intoxicating. “You can watch. From right there.” She pointed to a corner behind the suitcase, a niche of deep shadow. “You can see everything. You can hear everything. You can learn.”

The proposition was insane. Obscene. It clawed at every shred of Sarah’s decency. And yet, the heat between her legs, a heat first sparked by that video and stoked by Monica’s hands, flared into a desperate, consuming fire. The shame was there, acrid and choking, but it was being drowned out by a louder, more primal roar of curiosity. To see it live. To witness the reality of that power, that skill.

“I can’t,” Sarah whispered, but it was weak, a formality.

“You can. You will.” Monica’s hand came up, not in a caress, but to firmly tilt Sarah’s chin up, forcing their eyes to meet. “This is the only lesson I offer. Take it or leave it. But if you take it, you follow my rules. You don’t make a sound. You don’t move. You don’t touch yourself. You watch. You absorb. This isn’t for your pleasure. It’s for your education. Understood?”

Sarah felt dizzy. The world had narrowed to this mothball-scented closet, her stepsister’s piercing gaze, and the terrifying, magnetic pull of the forbidden. She saw her own pathetic reflection in Monica’s eyes. She saw the girl who borrowed sweaters and blushed easily. She didn’t want to be that girl in this moment. She wanted to be the girl who knew things.

She gave a single, sharp nod.

Monica’s lips curved. She released Sarah’s chin. “Good. Now fix your jeans. Go wait in the corner. And remember: not a sound.”

Numb, Sarah fumbled with her button and zipper, her fingers clumsy. She shuffled to the dark corner, squeezing behind the bulky suitcase. The floor was cold and hard. She pulled her knees to her chest, making herself small, invisible.

Monica gave the closet a once-over, adjusted a falling coat, and left, turning off the bare bulb as she went. The darkness was absolute, thick and swallowing. Sarah sat in it, listening to the frantic hammer of her own heart. She heard Monica moving in the bedroom beyond, the faint chime of a text message, the running of a faucet.

Time blurred. Every creak of the floorboard was Derek arriving. Her mind raced, picturing it, dreading it, craving it.

Then, the front door opened. Voices, low and familiar. Derek’s laugh, a rumble. Monica’s greeting, sweet and light—a performance.

“Missed you,” Derek said, his voice closer now, just beyond the closet door.

“I can tell,” Monica replied, a smile in her voice. There was a sound—a kiss, deep and wet. Sarah squeezed her eyes shut in the dark, as if that could block it out.

“Bedroom,” Derek murmured, a command.

“Wait,” Monica said, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper. “I’m feeling… adventurous. Come in here.”

The closet door opened. Light from the bedroom spilled in, outlining their figures in the doorway. Sarah held her breath, pressing her face against the rough canvas of the suitcase. Monica led Derek in by the hand. She didn’t glance toward Sarah’s corner.

“In here? Really?” Derek chuckled, a low, aroused sound. “Kinky.”

“You have no idea,” Monica said. She guided him to the center of the small space, right where Sarah had stood moments before. In the sliver of light, Sarah saw Monica sink to her knees. The sound of Derek’s zipper was a metallic shriek in the silent darkness.

What followed was not like the video. It was louder, messier, more visceral. The wet, sucking sounds were obscenely intimate. Derek’s sharp, guttural curses. The rustle of clothing. The creak of his knees as his stance widened. Monica’s low hums of approval.

Sarah watched, paralyzed. She saw the focused darting of Monica’s head, the expert use of her hands. She saw Derek’s fists clench at his sides, then tangle in Monica’s platinum hair. She saw the raw, unfiltered reality of it—the sloppy, devastatingly effective mechanics of pleasure. It was crude. It was magnificent. It was a masterclass in control, and Monica was in absolute command, directing every gasp and groan.

The education was brutal and complete. Sarah’s own body was a live wire of conflicting sensation—arousal so intense it was a pain, shame so deep it felt like dissolving, and a staggering, horrifying envy. She understood now, viscerally, what Monica had meant. This was power.

It ended with a choked, ragged sound from Derek and a long, tense silence broken only by heavy breathing.

Sarah closed her eyes, her own breathing shallow and silent. She heard the rustle of clothes, a soft kiss.

“Go pour us a drink,” Monica said, her voice slightly hoarse. “I’ll be right out.”

Derek mumbled something agreeable and stumbled out, leaving the door ajar. The light from the bedroom framed Monica as she stood slowly, smoothing her hair. She didn’t look at Sarah, not at first. She took a deep breath, straightened her jumpsuit, and walked to the sink in the adjacent bathroom. Sarah heard water run, the brief sound of gargling.

Then Monica returned to the closet doorway. She didn’t turn the light on. She simply stood, a silhouette, looking directly into the darkness where Sarah crouched.

Her voice, when it came, was a clean, cold whisper that cut through the thick, sex-scented air.

“So. Did you learn what you needed to know?” A pause, heavy with implication. “Or… would you like to watch me suck him off again next time?”

Monica’s whisper hung in the dark, a twisted invitation. Sarah couldn’t answer. Her throat was sealed shut by shame and a desperate, humming need.

From the bedroom, Derek called out, “Babe? You coming? The whiskey’s poured.”

Monica didn’t break her gaze from the dark corner. “Be right there,” she sang back, her voice sweet and light. Then, lower, just for Sarah: “Think about it.”

She turned and left, closing the closet door, plunging Sarah back into absolute blackness.

Sarah sat there, trembling. The sounds were over, but her body hadn’t gotten the memo. Every nerve was lit up, replaying the wet sounds, the shaky sighs, the raw image of Derek’s hips stuttering forward. She felt disgusting. She felt alive. The ache between her legs was a pounding, persistent throb. Monica’s rule—don’t touch yourself—felt like the cruelest joke ever conceived.

She didn’t know how long she sat there. Long enough for her legs to cramp. Long enough to hear the low murmur of the television through the wall. She finally stumbled to her feet, muscles protesting, and cracked open the closet door. The bedroom was empty, lit by a single lamp. The hall light was on.

She crept out, a ghost in her own skin. She could hear them laughing in the living room, the clink of glass. She had to get out. She grabbed her bag from the guest room, her hands shaking so badly she could barely zip it.

“Leaving so soon?”

Sarah froze. Monica leaned in the doorway of the guest room, a glass of amber liquid in her hand. She’d changed into a silky robe, loosely tied. Derek was nowhere in sight.

“I… yeah. I don’t feel well,” Sarah managed, not meeting her eyes.

“I bet you don’t.” Monica took a slow sip. “You look wrecked. Good wrecked, but wrecked.” She stepped fully into the room, closing the door softly behind her. “Did you like your lesson?”

“Stop calling it that,” Sarah hissed, a flash of anger cutting through the numbness.

“Why? That’s what it was. Fundamentals 101. You watched, you learned. I could see it on your face when you finally slunk out of there. You’re different now.” Monica set her glass down on the dresser. “You liked seeing him lose control like that, didn’t you? Knowing I was the one doing it to him.”

“I didn’t like any of it,” Sarah lied, her voice cracking.

“Liar.” Monica was in front of her now, so close Sarah could smell the whiskey on her breath, mixed with a faint, minty trace of mouthwash. “Your little crush on Derek just got a whole lot more complicated, huh? It’s not just about thinking he’s cute now. It’s about knowing exactly what his cock looks like when he’s about to come. It’s about knowing the sounds he makes.”

“I don’t have a crush on him,” Sarah whispered, mortified that Monica had somehow known.

“Please. You’ve been mooning over him since I brought him home for Thanksgiving. It’s pathetic.” Monica’s hand came up, not to strike, but to gently push a strand of hair behind Sarah’s ear. The contrast between the tender gesture and the vile words was dizzying. “But now it’s interesting. Now you want him for a real reason. Not because he holds doors open. You want him because you saw how animal he can get. You want to see if you can make him make those sounds.”

Sarah was crying again, silent, hot tears of humiliation. Because it was true. Every word was true. The fantasy had been sanitized before. Now it was filthy and specific and it clawed at her.

“He’s taking a shower,” Monica said, her voice dropping to a conspiratorial murmur. “Getting ready for round two. He thinks it’s his lucky night.” A slow, wicked smile spread across her face. “Want to see how it starts? The prelude? I could tell him to come in here. I could make him stand right there, in that doorway. And I could get on my knees again, for your benefit this time. A private tutorial.”

Sarah’s mind screamed no. Her body, traitorous and pulsing, screamed yes.

“You wouldn’t,” Sarah breathed.

“Watch me.”

Monica turned and walked to the bedroom door. She opened it and called out, her voice a lazy purr. “Derek? Bring your drink in here for a second.”

“What’s up?” His voice came closer, his footsteps padding down the hall. He appeared in the doorway, hair damp, wearing just a pair of low-slung sweatpants. He saw Sarah and raised an eyebrow, a friendly, oblivious smile on his face. “Hey, Sarah. You’re still here? Monica said you weren’t feeling good.”

“She’s feeling better,” Monica said, cutting off any reply Sarah could have mustered. She walked over to Derek, took the glass from his hand, and set it on the dresser. Then she placed her palms flat on his chest. “I’m not done with you yet.”

Derek chuckled, wrapping his arms around her waist. “Insatiable tonight.”

“You have no idea.” Monica glanced over her shoulder at Sarah, her eyes locking onto hers, holding her prisoner. Then she looked back at Derek, her hands sliding down his chest, over the ridges of his abdomen, to the waistband of his sweats. “I was thinking about your cock in my mouth the whole time you were in the shower. How fast I made you come. How you tasted.”

Derek’s easy smile faded, replaced by a look of intense focus. “Yeah?”

“Yeah.” Monica hooked her thumbs in the elastic. “I want to do it again. But slower this time. I want to taste every fucking inch of you. I want you to feel my tongue on that thick vein until you’re begging.” She said it all so calmly, so conversationally, while Sarah watched, frozen. “I want you to fuck my face properly this time. Not like in the closet where you were all polite. I want you to lose your damn mind and use me. Grab my hair and shove that dick down my throat until I gag. You think you can do that for me? Or are you going to be a gentleman again?”

Derek let out a shaky breath, his hands coming up to cup Monica’s face. “Jesus, Mon. You’re in a mood.” His words were thick with arousal.

“I’m in my mood,” she corrected, her voice dropping to a dirty whisper as she began to pull his sweats down. “Now shut up and let me suck your fucking dick. And don’t you dare close your eyes. You watch me. You watch every filthy thing I do to you.”

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI