Cover of The Second Coming of Broken Saints

The Second Coming of Broken Saints

Read the story

15 chapters · 22447 words · Read 1 times

An alternate universe where several of my favorite characters undergo serious angst for the men they love, and the love they feel hits them so much that it has them screaming and wailing and crying and begging for salvation to a god that won’t spare them. They also have to undergo a trial, a hardship, that leaves them emotionally destroyed but doesn’t stop them from pushing through and getting the happy ending they deserve with the men they love. This is a story that includes Father Jud Duplenticy from the movie Knives Out: Wake Up Dead Man. This is also a story about Father Paul Hill from Midnight Mass. Two priests who are given a second chance, undergo adversity with themselves and a world that wants them destroyed, and grapple with their sexuality as they fall in love with men who change their worldview on things so dramatically that it breaks them in half before they repair themselves anew. Jud falls madly in love with detective Benoit Blanc, and Paul finds that he’s in love with Riley Flynn so much that he almost burns for him. All characters in this story are in the same universe, and vampires and magic exists.

Chapter 13: Bound and Begging

The morning dawned soft and forgiving, a pale light filtering through the stained-glass panels to cast fractured saints across the rumpled black silk. The house held its breath in a comfortable quiet. Limbs were intertwined, a map of ownership written in faint bruises and dried sweat. There was no urgency, only the slow, syrupy drift of recovery.

Benoit woke first, as he often did, his detective’s mind clicking on before his body. He lay still, feeling the steady rise and fall of Jud’s back against his chest. He pressed a kiss to the junction of neck and shoulder, inhaling the scent of him—sleep and sex and something uniquely, fundamentally Jud. Across the vast bed, Riley was already awake, his fingers lazily tracing the line of Paul’s spine, earning a sleepy, contented murmur.

The day unspooled in a gentle ribbon. They moved through the sun-drenched rooms with a shared, unspoken languor. Jud made pancakes, his belly bumping the counter, and Paul fed him a strawberry with a giggle that was young and carefree. Benoit read the paper, one hand resting on Jud’s thigh as he sat beside him on the sofa. Riley tuned his guitar, filling the spaces with soft, aimless chords. They kissed for no reason. They cuddled on the wide porch swing, watching clouds smear across the blue. The ghosts were silent. The past was a closed book. Here, now, they were just four hearts beating in time, wrapped in a peace so profound it felt sacred.

As the sun began to bleed orange and purple behind the trees, the peace thickened into something else—a anticipatory charge. Looks lingered. Hands strayed. A slow, hungry smile from Riley was mirrored by a deliberate raise of Benoit’s brow. The promise from the previous night hung between them, a delicious debt about to be collected.

“Evenin’, darlins’,” Benoit drawled, setting his glass of iced tea down with a decisive click. “Feel like a game?”

Paul and Jud exchanged a glance, a flush creeping up their necks. They knew the game.

In the bedroom, the evening light through the red and blue glass bathed everything in a dusky, ecclesiastical glow. The tools were laid out with ritual care on the dresser: silken ropes, two thick, veined silicone dildos, and the now-familiar pink ensembles.

“Arms around each other,” Riley instructed, his voice low and warm.

Paul and Jud obeyed, turning to face one another. They pressed close, their swollen bellies a sweet impediment, their full breasts flattening together. Benoit and Riley worked in efficient tandem. Ropes were wound around their torsos, binding them breast-to-breast, hip-to-hip. Another loop secured their thighs together. They were trussed, a single, writhing entity. The pink stockings were rolled up their legs, the collars buckled snug, the long gloves slid up their arms. They were adorned offerings.

Then came the toys. Benoit coated one dildo with cool, slick lube, his eyes on Jud’s face. “Open up, sweetheart,” he murmured, his thumb stroking Jud’s lower lip before he guided the toy down between their pressed bodies. Jud gasped as the broad tip pressed against his soaked entrance. Benoit pushed it in, slow and inexorable, filling him until the silicone base nestled against his pussy lips. Jud’s head fell back with a choked moan.

Beside them, Riley did the same to Paul, watching his husband’s dark eyes flutter shut as the intrusion stretched him. “That’s it. Take it all. Greedy thing.”

Once both were fully impaled, their sheer pink panties were pulled up, the fragile fabric the only thing keeping the toys buried deep inside them. Every slight shift made them feel the weight, the fake fullness.

“Beautiful,” Benoit breathed, stepping back to admire his work. They were a picture of depraved captivity: bound, dressed in pretty pink, their cunts stuffed, utterly helpless. He leaned in, capturing Jud’s mouth in a deep, possessive kiss. “I need to run an errand. You be good for me.”

Riley cupped Paul’s face, kissing him with equal fervor. “Behave,” he whispered against his lips. “Don’t you dare come until we’re back.”

Then they were gone. The front door clicked shut. Silence, heavy and throbbing, descended.

For a moment, Paul and Jud just breathed, foreheads touching. The sensation was immediate and overwhelming. The toys inside them were a constant, maddening presence. Their bound position forced their sensitive, swollen pussies to rub together with every shallow breath, the panties providing a whisper of friction that was pure torture.

“Paul,” Jud whimpered, his hips giving an involuntary, tiny jerk.

“I know,” Paul gasped back. “Oh, fuck, I know.”

They began to move. It was a small, desperate grinding, their bodies sliding in the limited space their bonds allowed. The dildos shifted inside them, hitting deep, tender spots. Jud moaned, capturing Paul’s mouth in a wet, messy kiss. They kissed like drowning men, tongues tangling, teeth clashing. They were slick with sweat where their skin met, their leaking nipples pearling against each other’s chests.

“Can’t… can’t help it,” Paul sobbed, his own hips circling helplessly. The friction on his clit was unbearable. He was hurtling towards the edge, defiance of Riley’s command a fleeting thought obliterated by need.

Jud was right there with him, his breath coming in sharp, ragged pants. “It’s too much… Benoit…”

Their movements grew more frantic, a shuddering, clumsy dance of pure need. The ropes bit into their skin, a bright counterpoint to the blurring pleasure. Jud came first, a broken, airless cry against Paul’s shoulder, his cunt clenching wildly around the silicone toy, his whole body seizing. The intense pulses of his orgasm, the way his body convulsed against him, tore Paul over the edge a second later. He screamed, a raw, ugly sound, his own climax ripping through him like a storm, so intense his vision whited out.

They sagged in their bonds, sobbing, spent. But the toys were still there. The contact was still there. Their bodies, super-sensitized and begging for more, wouldn’t let them rest. Within minutes, the slow, hopeless grinding began again. A second climax followed, then a third, weaker but no less wrenching, leaving them trembling and slick with their own release, tears of overstimulation tracking through the sweat on their cheeks. They were a mess of whimpers and shallow kisses, utterly ruined, time dissolving into a haze of aching, repetitive pleasure.

The sound of the front door was salvation and judgment.

Footsteps on the stairs. The bedroom door opening. Benoit and Riley stood there, their eyes devouring the scene. Their bound, pregnant wives were glistening, weeping, their pink outfits stained, their legs shaky.

“Disobedient,” Riley tsked, though his voice was thick with arousal. He walked over, running a hand through Paul’s damp hair. “You came, didn’t you? I can smell it.”

“W-We couldn’t…” Paul tried to explain, his words slurred.

“Hush,” Benoit said, his voice a dark velvet promise. He didn’t untie them. He simply unzipped his fly, his hard cock springing free. Jud moaned at the sight. Benoit tugged the soaked panties down just enough, freeing the dildo, which slid out with a wet pop. He didn’t give Jud a moment to recover. He positioned himself and slammed in, burying himself to the hilt in Jud’s overstimulated, clenching channel.

Jud’s scream was pure, shattered ecstasy.

At the same moment, Riley entered Paul, his thrust just as brutal and deep. The bed, already straining, cried out in protest. The force of their husbands’ thrusts pushed Paul and Jud harder against each other, crushing their breasts, forcing their pussies to grind together even more fiercely.

It was an overwhelming sensory barrage. Jud felt Benoit pistoning into him, filling him with a breathtaking stretch, while Paul’s wet heat rubbed against his own swollen folds. Paul was lost in the same duality: Riley’s relentless pounding and the delicious friction of Jud against him.

“Fuck, that’s it, take it,” Riley growled, his hands gripping Paul’s bound hips. “This cunt is made for me. Milk my cock, you gorgeous bitch.”

Benoit was quieter, his intensity focused. He fucked Jud with a devastating, precise rhythm, leaning close to whisper in his ear. “This is what you are. Mine. This hungry, weeping hole is mine to breed. You’ll come again. Now.”

Orgams weren’t singular events; they were a relentless tide. Jud came, screaming Benoit’s name, his body bucking wildly within its constraints. Paul followed, his sob muffled against Jud’s collarbone. Their husbands didn’t stop. They shifted angles, changed pace, fucked them through the climaxes and into new, shuddering peaks. The room filled with the cacophony of flesh, desperate pleas, and the crude, beautiful language of possession.

Hours bled away. When Benoit finally spilled deep inside Jud with a guttural groan, and Riley emptied into Paul with a final, driving thrust, it was deep in the velvet night. They carefully cut the ropes. Paul and Jud collapsed, boneless and twitching, unable to support their own weight.

Riley gathered Paul into his arms, a wet, shuddering bundle of oversensitive nerves. Paul mumbled something entirely incoherent, nuzzling blindly into Riley’s neck, seeking the comfort of his skin. He was a mindless and incoherent pile in Riley’s arms.

Benoit did the same with Jud, cradling him close, stroking his hair as Jud trembled and made soft, whimpering sounds against his chest. Jud clung to him, his fingers weakly clutching Benoit’s shirt, wordlessly seeking kisses and cuddles, as spent and utterly owned as his brother in arms.

Read on DreamPress

Write your own erotic story with AI